Shallots, chives, capers, crme fraiche, soy, quail egg
5oz sliced, twice baked potatoes, asparagus, baby carrots, choice of herbed garlic butter, roasted shallot wine, shiitake brandy
New York Strip
wet aged, center cut
Outstanding as always! We were greeted by Mark and welcomed back! Eric was an amazing waiter and his attention to service was excellent! The food, wine and ambiance were amazing! To welcome us back they offered a complementary desert! To the entire team we say thank you!
It had been eight months since my last visit due to COVID. I was really excited and looking forward to finally eating at Carnevor. I ordered a med filet and received a very well done filet. The recooked filet came back near raw. The general manager who is a very nice guy offered to cook another one by then the experience was not very good I just settle for the near raw filet. The general manager didn’t charge me for the filet but I was very disappointed that the experience was not good. I live in Fond du lac so I don’t get down there often. I always believe in another chance but the expense to drive that far I will have to think before I make a another reservation. Just being honest as the staff at Carnevor is awesome...
It is rare to find a place where the steak is evenly cooked. Wet aging it certainly helps, but what happens in the kitche is key.
The shitake reduction sauce was not particularly shitake-ish, possibly for adding too much of whatever reduced it (wine) or because it was prepared in well in advance. A VERY minor flaw. I cannot wait to return.
Must go for a date night, or nice adult convo, in Milwaukee!
You can't go wrong with the Dry-aged NY Strip, but be prepared to pause your conversation, because, really, you'll need a moment with just you and your steak.
Fabulous dining experience. The food and service was excellent.
Best atmosphere, steaks, and fine dining experience in Milwaukee!!
The service was amazing and the food was just as spectacular. Will definitely go back here to dine again.
Great ambiance & food was delicious! Always go back for a special occasion!
Ask them to go light on the seasoning on the stakes. It’s a bit too salty for our liking. Been like that for our last couple visits, but since we only go once a year we forgot to ask for light seasoning.
This is my favorite steakhouse. The service is amazing and the steak was cooked perfectly. The Caesar salad is also one of my faves!!
The food was absolutely excellent. I don't know what they do, but the steaks are spectacular. Everyone in our party was extremely happy with our food. Best place to eat in Milwaukee.
We went to Carnevore to celebrate our anniversary. The experience was great. Food was amazing, as it always is, and they made the experience extra special for our special occasion.
A Happy Anniversary card greeted us at the table when we arrived. The service was impeccable. We never felt rushed like you often do in these covid times. The tuna tartare was the best we've ever had. We order it often and eat a lot of sushi. Salad course was also extraordinary. Our steaks and mashed potatoes with truffle and lobster were the best we have ever had. We are foodies and I expected a great meal because of their reputation but Carnevor far exceeded my expectations.
So very happy Omar and his amazing chef and staff are back to serving the BEST steaks in Wisconsin. We can’t wait to be back!
Amazing service, experience.
Premium pricing, quality food, executed quite well.
Fantastic steak. Just wish it was slightly less expensive so I can afford to come here again soon.
Thank you, Matt! We appreciate you coming in and look forward to seeing you again.
Everything was amazing! We will definitely be back!!
Thank you, Jeni! We can't wait to have you back.
The filet was amazing! We also had the butternut squash risotto and carmelized brussels sprouts. So yummy!
Thank you for dining with us! We're so glad to hear you enjoyed your visit.
Me & my fiancé had dinner for sweetest day
Thank you for choosing to celebrate with us! We appreciate your support.
Our dinner at Carnevor's was excellent, as usual. Our server, Diana, was outstanding! Thanks to all the staff!
Thank you for the kind words, John! We are so grateful for your support.
They made our dinner so special for my birthday! Food and service is on point! 1st timers and will be back every time we're in Milwaukee!
We appreciate you choosing to celebrate with us. Can't wait to see you again the next time you're in town!
Amazing food, great atmosphere, awesome service!!!
Thank you for dining with us! We're so glad to hear you enjoyed everything.
Fantastic service from Stan and outstanding food quality and presentation.
Thank you for dining with us, Scott! We're so glad to hear you had a great experience and look forward to seeing you again soon.
Awesome food and service as always this is our go to for steak
Thank you for the kind words! We look forward to seeing you again soon.
We went for our 2.5 year date, it was great!
We're so glad you chose to celebrate your special day with us! Thank you for stopping in.
The food was amazing along with the service and staffing!
We're so glad to hear you enjoyed your recent visit! Thank you for this great feedback. We hope to see you again soon.
The best steak in Milwaukee. Best service in Milwaukee. My wife had the ribeye and I had a filet and scallops. All were prepared to perfection. Stan our waiter has been there since day one and he was awesome. Only minor issues were it was louder than usual due to the presence of children which is unusual and the other is that it is very expensive. We go to Carnevor for birthdays and anniversaries and it is our favorite restaurant. Can’t wait to go back.
Thank you for choosing to celebrate your special occasions with us! We appreciate your continued support. We look forward to your next visit!
Everything was great
Thank you for dining with us! We're so glad to hear you enjoyed your visit.
This restaurant is always amazing. The staff is always friendly, the food is excellent, and they went above and beyond to make sure Covid safe. Had a wonderful birthday dinner for my husband!!
Thank you for choosing to celebrate your special night with us! We're so glad to hear you felt comfortable dining with us and enjoyed your visit. We look forward to seeing you again soon.
Great dinner. COVID policies in place to allow for touch free ordering. Good spacing of tables. Prompt and friendly service. Excellent meal.
Ryan, we appreciate your feedback and recognition of our health and safety efforts. We are so glad to hear you enjoyed your visit as well. Thank you for your support!
We wonderful Dining experience .
Took my Friend to a Wonderful Birthday dinner ... thank you for the BIRTHDAY dessert...
Thank you for choosing to celebrate your special night with us! We're so glad to hear you enjoyed your visit.
Covid hasn't stopped Carnivore! We had one of our best meals ever. Apps (bone marrow and squid), wedge salad, and steaks were delicious. Excellent wine list and cocktails. Everything was delicious. Thank you!
Thank you so much, Scott! We appreciate your support and are glad to hear you had a great experience. We hope to see you again soon!
Celebrated our anniversary here and was blown away by the food and service! They even had a card at our table congratulating us. Our one complaint was that we were seated next to a large group talking business that really raised the level of noise in that area of the restaurant - not exactly the most romantic thing to yell over their conversation. Once they left the noise level was much better and we were able to enjoy the rest of our meal.
Thank you for choosing to celebrate with us! We're so glad to hear you enjoyed your visit. We will take your feedback about the noise level into consideration and work on ways to improve our guest experience. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Always an amazing dinner and fantastic service. Best steak house we've been to. Great Service, Great Ambiance. Wonderful evening.
Thank you, Ryan! We're so grateful for your support and incredible feedback. We look forward to seeing you again soon.
Had a great steak house experience. Steaks were fabulous. Sides were great. Service and ambiance were great. Would highly recommend.
Thank you for your great feedback! We hope to see you again soon.
Such a fantastic as always at Carnevor! The domestic Wagyu filet is AMAZING!!
Thank you, Wayne! We are so glad to hear you enjoyed your recent visit. We look forward to seeing you soon.
Great food but atmosphere is a little dark and meal felt rushed.
We appreciate your feedback about the food, atmosphere and service. We will take your comments to our team to work on ways to improve the overall guest experience. We hope to see you again soon.
Everything was incredible and the service to the food everything was top notch. My wife and I are treated like kings and queens but for the service you also pay a lot of money
We're so glad to hear you enjoyed your visit! We hope you join us again sometime soon.
Stan was our waiter and he was incredibly knowledgeable and attentive. All of the food is out of this world! From all meat crab cakes, to steaks seasoned and cooked to perction, to the lobster ( huge pieces)truffles mashed! Donuts are one of their many desserts that are so good! Ugh! There is no place that can compare!
Thank you for joining us, Steph! We're so glad to hear you enjoyed your visit with us and appreciate this great feedback. We hope to see you again soon!