Five Mile Stone
Great food and EXCELLENT service
Very good experience. Food was good, service was good and given the outdoor set-up, a very positive and enjoyable time!
Robby the Manager and Sharon the waitress are incredible in all the do at Five Mile Stone!
The service was fast, but the hamburger was super dry and mac&cheese was plain, not enough cheese, just expensive pasta with a little cheese on top.
Outstanding bar food, service, and menu variety. While we had to eat outdoors, like everyone else in NYC, we were warm and comfortable. After spending twice and even three times as much on fancy restaurants where we did not necessarily leave feeling as if the food warranted our return, we will be sure to come back many times to this fine emporium. Authentic Irish pub with all of the fixings!
Great cocktails and wings, very safe outdoor seating set-up with spacers between tables and good ventilation!
Always a great experience. This is my go-to neighborhood place. Their outdoor seating was heated and nice, and the winter cocktails were awesome too! Food is always good.
The restaurant was so nicely decorated for Christmas with a cozy indoor ambience. Covid rules were applied at all times in all areas and it felt safe. It’s a big place with two floors. All of the staff was beyond exceptional in service and friendliness. The Food was delicious as well. The Restaurant also has a good amount of outdoor space and the balcony seating is lovely. We wish owners and all staff health, well being and a hopefully soon return to normal service since sadly we are now going into another indoor dining lock down!
Great food and wonderful service. I would recommend to make a reservation.
Dylan was fabulous!
Went on a busier Saturday so we had to wait 20 minutes even though we had a reservation but we got a free round of shots and that more than made up for it! Drinks and food
Well managed social distancing, clean and comfortable. Bar and comfort food done well, with a reasonable selection of beers with an Oktoberfest theme. Great service from the Irish lad and open to a reasonable hour, which is hard to find these days
The food was great
Food was delicious! Went for brunch-I live in the neighborhood and haven't been there in years. Glad I gave it another try. A nice brunch spot
The restaurant has handled their outdoor space well, and the food preparation & service were just fine. The menu is much reduced, however, and we would not have chosen this restaurant if we had known that - we were coming to enjoy items which were not available.
I had a nice dinner here with a friend on a Friday night. The food was very good and it was a nice portion. They also have a good selection of cocktails, wine, and beer. They did a great job spacing out the tables for outdoor dining.
First brunch out for Phase 2 and it was great! The service was excellent and quick and we felt very safe!
Five Mile Stone is my go to place for great food and service in a relaxed atmosphere for a reasonable price. I highly recommend it for a fun time with friends.
I ordered a drink when the server came over. I never received it and then when he finally came back I said I wanted a Guinness and he hadn't even ordered it. We waited 30 minutes for our drink to arrive. The food came out quick though and it was pretty good. We decided against having another drink because the first one took so long. We couldn't find our server to get the check and the busboy got it for us and ran our card for us. It wasn't even that busy so I'm not sure why service was so bad.
Even with a reservation they tried to seat us at a table just by the door and only “found” another table when we insisted. Loud, even upstairs. Chicken wings very dried and the avocado toast just ok. The only good thing was the Bellini that my friend had. I won’t be repeating anytime soon
Service was ok at best. Food was good. too much salt and butter on everything. wasn't anything special.
The Shepard's Pie offered little meat and lots of bland mashed potatoes. It was not a flavorful dish.
Stick with the burger - its good although expensive ($18) for what this place js which is a bar that has food. Nice selection of beer.
This is a bar/restaurant with a lot of character. The food is delicious and reasonably priced. The atmosphere was very loud on a Saturday evening so it was not the optimal place for conversation. Would definitely return.
The oysters were truly disgusting, and I will always eat oysters -- these I left on my plate. Burger redeemed my experience.
First time here, on Christmas Day.
Great ambiance and super friendly staff. Enjoyed everything about experience.
Always a pleasure eating brunch here. Staff and managers are great. No complaints!
Love, love, love the food!!!!
Was amazing and by far our favorite NY bar. Great food, and great place to watch football too!
Can be loud Friday night and Saturday night. To avoid it stay on the 1st floor. Great food. Burgers are great, so are crab cakes, calamari, and pizza. Duck was so so. Owner always checks on our table and staff are helpful. A good part of the year they get fresh lobster for dinner. Love that! They also are handicapped accessible.
Four of us ate here and happened to arrive in time for the half price beer and wine, which was nice. Our server was very attentive, and a manager also checked on us throughout the meal. Two at the table got the ribs and loved them. They were great about allowing switches on the types of fries and both the tater tops and the shoestring fries were good. The third person got a burger and enjoyed it. I ordered the pasta and vegetables, which would have been great except that the dish was overseasoned with peppercorns that were so spicy they made my eyes water. Not sure why that was necessary when there was salt and pepper at the table. Prices were reasonable for a NY restaurant. Would go back again.
Great food and beer + great $1 oysters. Gem of a place in UES!
Food and service were excellent. Servers were in Halloween costumes, which was fun. The fish tacos were the best.
The staff is very welcoming and accommodating. Have eaten here many times because the quality of the food is consistently excellent. I highly recommend it for casual dining.
Looks nothing like their site photos. Layer of grease everywhere, 150% casual, TVs, friendly host, not the most hospitable nor professional bartenders—both were interested in joking and conversing than providing proper dining service, no water, and unapproachable. Happy hour was convenient but oysters were not fresh. Ambiance is noisy with TVs. Convenient and fitting for families and tourists.
It is a very nice bar to see a game and catch up with friends. The prices were decent. The staff was great and I appreciated that the music was at a good level. I could hear my conversations which was very nice.
I was very disappointed this evening. It was not very busy and the food took forever. My duck was very tough and not up to its usual standards and they over cooked the burger and had to redo it. The Kitchen Staff was the problem, and they need to be made aware as there is Too Much competition in this City to NOT be on point with simple items!
I assume you have a new “chef” the Caesar salad, which I use to live was totally different in a bad way
The hostess who took my reservation was especially nice and accommodating, both on the phone and in person. Food was delicious, everyone in our party of 6 really enjoyed their meal. The portion were especially large. I had fish and chips and couldn’t finish everything . Will definitely come back!!!
The gathering of friends on the reserved table was very idealistically appropriate for it set the mood for a wonderful gathering. It is most certainly a place that I will be visiting again. The service was exemplary with a certain casual vibe that was very accommodating but still keeping a personal amendable customer care to the restaurant that seems to be diminishing in this new wave or dining out.
OpenTable ダイナー149名によるFive Mile Stoneの評価は4.6☆です。