Five O'Clock Steakhouse
Porterhouse Steak (Five O'Clock Cut)
For The Hearty Eater - Specially Selected - The Finest
Handcut Steak Fries
12 oz USDA Prime Delmonico Steak
Roasted Garlic-Chili Oil Rub, Seaweed Rice, Sesame Asparagus Suggested Pairing: Brancaia "TRE" - Toscana, Italy $12 / $44
This is my favorite place to eat at. I always bring friends and family here for special occasions. From the moment you walk in the door until you leave is amazing service guaranteed as well as the food always being so amazing! If I could give this place more than 5 stars I would. 🙌🏽
The food was great! However, it was difficult to enjoy with the constant interruptions from staff, we felt rushed by staff to eat, drink and leave. There was someone at our table every 2 minutes, we had several people walk up to us and put a "Reserved" sign on our table before we even got our food. A number was then added, and staff for other tables standing at ours. Never once were the sign or numbers explained to us, or even an "excuse me for the interruptions". Very difficult to enjoy ourselves and carry on a conversation. There were several open tables when our food arrived so we don't understand the need to rush. I've been to this restaurant many times over the years and never experienced this.
With that said the food did not disappoint!
The food was amazing and the service staff were knowledgeable, helpful and attentive.
Eric is a fantastic waiter, overall service was excellent. Can’t wait to come again.
The food & customer service was amazing I will definitely go back
A sort of up north kind of vibe..old steakhouse! The steaks are excellent & so big!
Alwsys a great dining experience
Food is delicious
Excellent service and really good food - steak was one of the best I’ve had in Milwaukee!
We will be back
Fantastic steakhouse. Best prime rib I have ever had. Joanie was great. Thank you for a fabulous evening.
Terrific service. Do not think we went 5 minutes without being checked in on. Food came out very fast and was amazing. Spent our anniversary here and they gave us a complimentary dessert as well. Awesome place and will definitely be back
Love this place! so glad to have been back. Chef was awesome!
Absolutely excellent from the time you are greeted by an armed security guard who opens the door for you, the pre seating at the bar to go over the menu and meet your waitress/waiter until the time you are seated at your table for the evening!!
The music was phenomenal as well. Definitely one of our favorites.
We are from San Francisco, a place well known for great restaurants, but not steakhouses. We had heard a lot about Five O'Clock, and it didn't disappoint. It's so old school, that it transcends time. They have gone out of their way to keep the decor as close to the 1940s original as possible, including keeping the original carpet. But the real star of the show is the food. It's so rare for a famous institution to live up to the hype. My rib-eye was in the top five I have ever eaten. What ever jus they use, it's spectacular. It was one of the most perfect medium rare cook temperatures I have even seen. The whole experience was delightful and I highly recommend making an evening of it. Appetizers and entrees were excellent. Cocktails were watered down. Stick with wine. Desserts were solid, if a little uninspired.
Would Highly Recommend. Best Steakhouse in Milwaukee hands down.
Lots of fun. Lively place with old school charm! Great food and friendly service!
The greatest food, greatest service, greatest restaurant ever!
Literally never disappoints
First dinner out in over a year because of the pandemic. A great way to celebrate vaccination. Excellent steaks. Great service. Perfect supper club atmosphere. Great safety practices. Awesome valet parking. It was a perfect night out.
Greatest place for steaks and a date! Highly recommended!
As always, great experience.
A great supper club in the downtown area. We will go back soon!
Loved the experience, food was excellent. Very enjoyable experience, can’t wait to visit again
Food is always EXCELLENT! The live music was a little loud at the bar but once we sat at our table it was perfect. The guy played well for the span of ages present. Service was impeccable and easy going which we loved! The ambiance is classic Wisconsin supper club!
Strength was service/timing and COVID protocols. Delightful waitress and staff. Drawback was food quality. Steaks had an excess of an overpowering very dark-colored au jus and the cut of beef was not as expected for the money. BBQ rib appetizer was great, exceptional sauce. Potatoes were typical, salads also. Overall the meal was all right but not in line with the prices. Restaurant was busy on this Tuesday night, good to see.
I have been going here for years. It's as good as it gets with it's own unique down home style. It's not just fine dining, it's an experience!
Everything was great, service top notch. Can’t ask for a better experience in the city.
An amazing me and amazing service as aways!!! The scallops were amazing!
Server was marginal. Felt rushed to table so another group didn’t take it. Only 3 of 5 given menus. Had to share. Soup and salad came at same time. Salad was dull. Relish tray was quite small. Server never asked for more drinks or how anything was. Owner had to take our bill since she was no where around. Disappointed!!
Possibly the best steak I have ever had. Can’t wait to go back!
Felt a little rushed. No room at bar to sit and have a drink and order. Very small table in Alley Cat Lounge. Nice but main dining area much nicer. Will always be my favorite!
All of the staff wore masks. Thanks. The plastic dividers between the tables gave us a sense of security and we appreciated that.
The drinks were generous pours, thanks.
We've had the restaurant on our bucket list for 10 years. This was our first night and we'll be back.
My bone-in rib-eye was cooked perfectly. For the price I thought it could have been trimmed a bit more. The flavor from the fat/marbling should come from within the cut not from the fat on the outside of the meat.
The dark brown juice that covered the steak was just ... OK. I'm a purest and enjoy a well aged cut of beef that can stand on it's own without adding gravy-juice for flavor. When I opened my leftovers up at home the color of the juice is off-putting. Thank goodness it's dark in the restaurant.
After the meal no one offered coffee or an after-dinner drink. This made me feel rushed. I get the pandemic has made your business life rough and I get table turn, but don't make it too obvious.
For the price the desserts, they could have been more generous. My carrot cake was dry and must have been either pre-cut or sitting in a frig. The real whipped cream is a nice touch.
I'll give it a 4.5 overall in stars......and we'll be back.
The food was amazing, but the char on the steak was too over-powering; just tasted burnt. It may have been to hold in the flavor, but in reality it took away from it. Everything else was great, would definitely come back 👍
Great service and Food was spot on !!! Highly recommend for a good steak !
We’ve been there many time and the food is always awesome and the service is fantastic!
The ambiance was nice but wasn’t overly impressed with the food.
We were intrigued by the restaurant’s reputation as the best steakhouse in Milwaukee, and wanted a good steak before leaving the Midwest at the end of the month. We were on a tight timeline-our reservation time was the soonest we could arrive from Madison and just before our vaccine appointments. I called Five O’Clock Steakhouse to order ahead, and they were extraordinarily accommodating. They had salad ready for us the moment we sat down— the house-made blue cheese dressing was lovely. The rest of the orders came like clockwork. We preordered the steak frites and the green beans almondine, both delicious accompaniments to the perfectly medium-rare filet mignon, tender, juicy, and full of savory flavor. I only regret not having enough time to order the Cherries Jubilee for dessert.
Coming here was a real treat, both for the food and the caring service. If we ever find ourselves in the Midwest again, we’ll make our way to Five O’Clock.
I heard they have some of the best steaks in town so the wife and I decided to try it out. The food was good just not what I was expecting. My steak was tough, maybe it was the way I had it cooked. I wanted medium well. Other than that everything was great. I would go back.
ALWAYS received great service AND great food on every occasion. Took my current girlfriend for her birthday and she loved it too !
One of the truly great “Supper Clubs” of Wisconsin!
OpenTable ダイナー2596名によるFive O'Clock Steakhouseの評価は4.7☆です。