Not Your Average Joe's Randolph
Food was so nasty would never go back there and over price
Excellent service, manager gave us an excellent table for our valentines dinner, great food. Will come back
I love this restaurant for so many reasons. First, their menu is outstanding giving options to a wide variety of foodies. Whether you are a true carnivore or plant based, gluten free or allergy sensitive, the menu has many options and is labeled appropriately. Second, can we discuss the bread? Ugh! I could make a whole meal of just that! The service is always top notch and specifically for Valentines Day, their specials were fantastic. Repeat customer for life!
Needed to get in & out for a movie. Thought we'd only have time for apps. Server assured us we would have time. Our meal was quick but not rushed. Lobster ravioli was delicious.
Went on a first date here and had appetizers as well as a few drinks. Food was good and the drinks were good as well.
I found the shrimp cocktail and filet mignon with mushrooms, mashed potatoes and grilled asparagus to be delicious. It was gluten free as well, and I was not contaminated by cross contamination either. So it was a wonderful meal for me and my friend loved the lobster ravioli.
Great cocktails!!! Healthy food options. Keto vegetarian, ect. Waited less then 10 minutes on a Saturday night.
I ordered a Cobb salad and there was a piece of plastic wrap inside of it. It didn’t bother me any, I still ate the salad I just gave the plastic to the waitress. She didn’t even say she was sorry about it that’s what got me.
This is my guaranteed delicious go to restaurant. Love the food, service is always good and the availability is great. It’s a place of comfort.
Always do, always will. One of my favorite places to dine.
Chicken and shrimp bowl is DELICIOUS...a great addition to an already good menu
Steak frites was very good. Service was spot on. Very reasonable prices.
Had a really good experience for dinner! Food was good and the service friendly- though it was very loud...difficult to converse just across the table. Wouldn’t stop us going again but might hesitate with a larger party.
The waitress was a little rude at times. The chicken enchiladas which were one of the best menu items was removed last year they brought back a chicken enchiladas this month as a special they were no where close to the amazing enchiladas they has led in the past. Celebrating my birthday didn’t feel that special.
We were sat promptly and our server was great.
Good service, but chicken was light on pasta and was drowning in sauce. Wife said her salad was very good.
We had three people in our party and two wouldn't eat their food. My chicken had the burnt flavor which made me not eat the chicken portion of my meal. It's unfortunate as I always felt NYAJ was consistently good.
Perfect for Xmas eve dinner
I frequent your location quite often. This particular night was with my friends. It was very quiet and easy to talk and hear each other. The food was delicious timing was perfect. If I had a complaint it would be the bar closed too early. We were ready to have another glass of wine but was told no more drinks. It was 9. We just assumed that you weren't taking any reservations after 9 but that you would still be open.
We will try to do this again but get there earlier, thank you very much.
Food was GREAT and the wait staff wonderful. The hostess when entering the restaurant was extremely rude and arrogant... time to get someone who wants to be there and represent your restaurant appropriately.
always feel like I am at home and treated like a VIP thanks to Oksana at the Bar, she is the absolute best and ask for the muddled Jalapeno Margarita :)
Great food and great service as usual! Our party of six all enjoyed their meals. Nice to know that one in our party can also get a great meal that meets dietary/allergy restrictions. Thanks!
U shaped booth next to our booth was not level and 5 people were served beverages and they ended on floor. One of the patrons pants were all wet and server didn’t appear to be concerned. Ultimately they all moved to a new location. Obviously the table needs some fixing but I question if it will be fixed.
Always a good take. Love to see the seasonal menu!
Place was empty but our server rushed us
Great food went for the hamburger special on Tuesday night. Ask for Melissa she's very good.
Chicken was a little over cooked but still very good. Server was lovely.
Fun night out with the kids
Ahi tuna wontons appetizer excellent. Herb crusted baked haddock was overcooked. BBQ meatloaf very good. Ambience is rather dated. Joe's should consider updating décor.
Unfortunately service was very slow even though it was not terribly busy. We were still waiting for our food when people who came in after us were just finishing their meals. We had a special food request and when our food finally came it had not been done so back went one meal and we had another 6 minute wait.
Food very slow to come out. 45 minutes for two pizza’s and two grilled items. Food came out bland and not very good. Not sure how you screw up pizza but we’ve had better. We won’t go back.
Not Your Average joes is our ‘go to’ local restaurant...outstanding bread/dipping oil, good food, nice environment, good service.
ordered a large pizza it came overdone and the crust was burnt could not eat it at the end of the meal I said to our waiter the crust is burnt yes so I see I'll pack it up for you to take home I didn't like it in the restaurant so why would I like it at home he never suggested to redo another one or remove it from the bill as it was I had to throw it out at home that's how bad it was it was not a good a meal as we usually have
Went there with my brother who is special needs. Waitress was super friendly and very sweet and good with him!
Pizza, jambalaya and salad - yummy!!!!!
Had lunch with a school friend I had not seen in 40 years! I had never eaten at a Not Your Average Joe's before, so wasn't sure what to expect. The server was an absolute delight - friendly, funny, attentive but not overbearing. The food, however, was a complete disappointment. I ordered the Margherita Pizza. It was cold when it arrived, and was a TINY size with basically no more than the skimpiest layer of cheese. My friend fared better with her chicken caesar salad. We had a glass of wine each, but two simple lunch dishes and two glasses of wine came to over $80!! Won't be going back. Sorry.
The only thing I don't understand is why you don't still have green beans on the menu.
It was a great time and service was great! Having the reservation was nice and not having to wait was a bonus!!
We have eaten their a few times and the food has been consistently
Great service, delicious food, and a nice ambiance! We will be back!