Octopus salad was inedible. Worst ever. Rest of meal was good. Server, not service, was great.
Not recommend for the price.
Warm burrata caprese was outstanding. I had the Grouper. It was by far the best grouper I've had in a long time. Perfectly seared, flaky and buttery. I would definitely recommend and will absolutely be back!
Perhaps the best seafood we have ever enjoyed in St Augustine. Grouper was amazing!
The food and the service was excellent. I recommended.
Such a beautiful restaurant in St. Augustine. Great atmosphere and outstanding service.
Really nice place, although VERY loud. Also LED lighting gives a very “white light” to the room. Service was excellent as was food. Would like them to “tone it down” (lighting and volume) for a more intimate setting (as food menu deserves)! Overall excellent night! Would go back!!
Fantastic food and service! One of the best Italian meals I have ever had!
Loved it! Great staff. Delicious meal. Gorgeous atmosphere
This was our first dining experience here and wouldn’t return. The restaurant was very loud, Food was not very good. I had pasta with clams and the dish was very “gritty” and every bite was like chewing dirt....very disappointing. There are just so many wonderful restaurants in St Augustine I would just pass on this one!
Best food we had in a really long time. Wait staff was very friendly and helpful. Will be going back next time we are in town.
Overall an outstanding dining experience. Alta Marea is a terrific addition to Old Town St Augustine. Interior is upscale Mediterranean, menu features modern twists on classic Italian dishes, and location is excellent. Our server did a very nice job, but there were some lapses from the kitchen that led to a few slow spots. Given that this is a new restaurant and we were there on a Saturday night, we were not too disappointed. Prices are high, but for upscale seafood in St Augustine we were willing to pay for a special night out.
Our server Ryan was fantastic. The food was delicious. LOVED the atmosphere-so nice to add a refined restaurant to our community.
Fresh pasta was excellent. The homemade bread was great. Peter gave us excellent service and was extremely attentive and nice. Would go again solely based on the food and service.
20 year anniversary. Great way to celebrate
Wow so great that we now have 5 start restaurant in downtown. Can’t wait to go back and work our way down the menu
This restaurant is outstanding. Excellent food and great, friendly service. We had the veal chop and rack of lamb - both were exceptional. Stacey at the bar is top notch. Great wine list too.
I highly recommend Alta Marea. We will go back again and again.
Wonderful service and ambiance. Homemade bread and pasta. The food is fantastic. We will be back.
Met our exceeded expectations
The food was good and service exceptional. However, in these days of COVID we were disappointed to see service staff and bartenders without masks. In fact, the maitre d’ didn’t wear one the entire time 😕. Initially they tried to sit us within 6 feet of another table. They were a bit perplexed when we asked for another seat, but eventually complied with our request.
This was our first visit. Can’t wait to return. A perfect Italian coastal cuisine experience. We tried flavor combinations we never would have normally and they were delightful. The extensive white wine list provided a perfect accompaniment to the lovely flavor combinations. I would add this new hot spot to my frequent dining list. The service was stellar. This place will quickly rise to the top of the SA dining scene.
We came here for my boyfriends birthday. The food was outstanding, the service was wonderful, and the portions were pretty large! We are still talking about how delicious it was!
Fantastic service and wonderful food! Will absolutely be back to enjoy more of this new gem in a great part of old town!
Excellent restaurant, our meal was five star. The service was very good. The only complaint is the acoustics in the restaurant is poor. Very loud and difficult to hold a conversation when the place was full. Will definitely dine there again, but will have to factor in the noise level.
Wow! What an incredible new addition to Saint Augustine. Everything was outstanding and we cannot wait to come back.
A wonderful fine dining experience! Great food and service.
Amazing food and service. When we're back in town, we'll definitely be visiting again!
The food was so good, you MUST try their octopus (we had the octopus salad), and I also enjoyed my pistachio crusted lamb chop. The servers were attentive and nice. It’s definitely pricier, but it’s worth it for a special dinner!
Great find!! This place had only been open 2 weeks when we visited. The food, service, and ambience were superb.. Ryan was awesome as our server... Will be back!! Thank you.
Hidden gem. Fantastic service. Great food and drinks. We will be back!
Menu is a bit exotic by St. Augustine standards and a little pricey. No choices for kids. The food is outstanding and service is impeccable, with charming ambiance right in the heart of town. This is definitely more of a higher-end dinner outing than most other local restaurants. Some of the items we tried with our group were the caprese, beet salad, lamb chops, porcini lasagna, charcuterie, steak... all absolutely delicious. Loved it and will be back!
Beautiful restaurant with excellent food. Homemade breads and pastas. Highly recommend this restaurant.
Service was terrible and they were out of several things
OpenTable ダイナー32名によるAlta Mareaの評価は4.7☆です。