Brewsters Italian Cafe
pick (2) regular toppings on a traditional crust pizza; upcharge for other pizzas - ask your server
Spinach Artichoke Dip
served w/ rustic flatbread
homemade marinara & meatballs over long pasta
Always love Brewster's! Consistently good food and service. The dinner for 2 is our favorite;
Brewsters has been a family tradition for almost two decades. It’s truly a wonderful end to our spring/summer/fall weeks. Not only is the menu remarkable- I can remember when it changed daily even- but the service is second to none. As someone who spends their fare share of dinners in fine dining establishments I’d easily say Brewsters is my absolute favorite experience. The entire staff is warm and welcoming from the front end (shoutout to Abigail and the other gals!) to the incredible servers (we love everyone but are pretty darn partial to Kathleen) and the incredible and consistent kitchen. I don’t want the competition for a garden table but if you’re contemplating Brewsters do yourself a favor- thank me later!
One of our favorite patios. We always try to eat here when we are in New Buffalo. We could have stayed all afternoon but had to get on the road to drive back to Chicago. Love this place and the food and service!
We ate outside, and the setting was beautiful. The server was competent and funny, and the food excellent. We love this place!
Food was fantastic. Waitress was awesome! Can’t wait to go back
Brewster’s is the best in the area IMHO. Great food, service, and ambiance. Prices are very reasonable for quality of food. Their two for $45 dinner is such a great deal. Ahi tuna appetizer is easily a meal. Have heard lasagna is great.
Everything was great. Enjoyed a nice lunch with friends on the patio.
Great outdoor environment. Good food and friendly service
Eaten here many times. Food is consistent. Their outdoor patio and inside bar seating is best. It's not a big place and reserves out fast on Open Table. However the food is vg and reasonably priced for the new Buffalo area. The best seafood Italian is The upscale Terrace Room in the Harbor Grand down the street. Great place to people watch. Great chef!!!!! Pricey for the region but normal compared to the hip "she she" elitist places in Chicago (where many of New buffalo's visitors come from and sustain this resort town)
We love the place. The food is consistent and very good. The servers are extremely nice and competent. Reasonable price. Locally owned. New Buffalo still has a quaint feel.
Outside patio feels like a hidden garden! Food and service consistently meet/exceed expectations. Kate was an excellent server who was attentive without hovering or being bothersome. Rustic steak salad NEVER disappoints.
Extremely overrated dining experience. Food was no better than Olive Garden, and in fact Olive Garden is better. I have no idea what we spent $120 on. We were very dissatisfied and disappointed.
We celebrated our anniversary and the staff were awesome from the moment we got there. We arrived a few minutes early for our reservation and we were seated right away with a greeting of “Happy Anniversary!”
The food was timed perfectly. It was superb. Server was top notch remembering everything asked.
The ambience was beautiful. Weather was perfect.
Safety precautions for COVID were in place.
We loved our time together at Brewster’s. Can’t wait to go back.
My wife and I celebrated our tenth anniversary here. We were looking for something other than the norm, but still reasonable for our budget. We had never been to Brewsters, but had heard it was great. We were not disappointed, rather, amazed.
From the moment the hostess greeted us we treated as a frequent customer. The waitress was extremely patient and kind (we’re not accustomed to authentic dining). Wish I could remember her name (I’d drop it here!).She was very helpful.
I absolutely love Italian and Brewsters does it up right. I highly recommend this fine place to everyone. We will definitely be back. Maybe next time for pizza!
Always a wonderful experience. The food and ambiance are outstanding.
Staff was friendly food was amazing - I’m vegan and they accommodated me as well as my date. Would definitely eat here again!
We had a fantastic dinner. Split a spinach and artichoke dip then I had the tiger shrimp and sausage with artichoke hearts, spinach, red peppers in a delicious sauce with fresh pappardelle. Dh had chicken Alfredo, also delicious! We sat outside and it was just a perfect night to celebrate our wedding anniversary! I wish we lived closer but heading back to NYC tomorrow.
We enjoyed Brewster’s as usual, we eat here every few weeks. Food is always good and service is usually good. Noise level can be quite loud if you sit near bar.
Brewster's Italian Cafe is cozy, classy and comfortable. The creative cocktails offer a great break from usual beverage selections. You can order classic Italian cuisine or dishes with refreshing spice combinations. The menu has something for everyone. Service was prompt, upbeat and professional. Do make a reservation!
Outdoor dining has wonderful ambiance. Food was very good, overall service was average.
Brewsters is an excellent food. We ate at the patio, great setting. Both the food and service was great. The bruschetta is a must have.
We LOVE Brewster's and particularly the gardend! The ambience is spectacular, hushed, very appropriate music, beautiful weather (you should take credit for that also). I TREAT in every respect. Thanks to ALL from kitchen to mgmt....we appreciate everything you present.
Dennis L. Bowen
St. Joseph MI
Superb food, great staff. Ask for Dan. Sit outside if you can. Best restaurant in south west michigan
Our server was fabulous, the food was fantastic! Such a beautiful setting outside, we felt like we were in Tuscany. We look forward every summer to going to Brewsters! You will not be disappointed!!!!!!
I love Brewster's patio and ambience and the staff is great, but the food seems to be slipping a bit. One person at our table ordered lasagne and he thought it was just ok. I had the mahi mahi and while the fish was good, the couscous it was on was really awful, really awful. I'd recommend the pizza and pasta selections although again the lasagne was just ok.
Food was amazing! Incredible coffee! We’ll be back!
First time at the restaurant and it was such a great experience! Will definitely return in the future.
Food and everything was delicious. Server did the best she could. I think the kitchen was understaffed and too busy because our food took an hour. Luckily we got an appetizer and a bread basket that kept us satisfied til our dinner came.
Food and ambiance were excellent. Very busy, and service was a little slow. Overall, excellent.
The staff is so friendly, the food is delicious and we love the atmosphere. A wonderful local place.
The restaurant is absolutely adorable, so quaint. The food is delish. The price is $$$ ala carte / drinks as well...
Will have to go back!
We were in New Buffalo for the weekend to celebrate 10 years together. Picked Brewsters as we’ve never visited. They did not disappoint. Food, service and ambiance were all excellent. Looking forward to our next visit!
Amazing waitstaff! Seated promptly after arriving and the food was delicious!
This is our favorite restaurant to eat. Service is top notch, food is 5 star. We always bring friends and sit outside in the beautiful patio.
Lovely outdoor garden. Italian cuisine and service second to none!
Excellent seafood pasta entrees. Huge too. We took half home. Nice setting. Great service, especially considering the crush of Labor Day business.
My favorite local Italian restaurant! Apps, entrees, drinks and dessert were perfect!
Brewsters is fabulous. I live in California now, but when in the Midwest always make an effort to visit. Wonderful pastas, service is always friendly. Reservations are a must to get a table.
Something special … sat in outdoor patio where ambiance and service were second to none! Lovely experience.
Lovely late lunch outside on a beautiful day!
Brewsters Italian Cafeはテイクアウトにも対応しています。テイクアウトはお電話（(269) 469-3005）でご注文ください。
OpenTable ダイナー679名によるBrewsters Italian Cafeの評価は4.8☆です。