Even though I thought I booked a reservation for 12 and it turned out to be 2 the staff was great getting us a table for 12! Thank you Carmellas
Great menu with tons of choices.
We go 1-2 x a week. My 4 year olds favorite place. The waiters and waitresses are so friendly to him. Always consistent food.
We are regular patrons. Always a good experience
Great food and fantastic service!
Everything was fine at Carmella's, as usually. Great service, gret food, very fair prices.
I do have a complaint about using OpenTable to make a reservation. I made the reservatio an hour on advance AND received an email confirmation, however when we showed up at the restaurant Open Table had not yet called the restaurant and notified them of the reservation. As it worked out Carmella's was able to seat us immediately.
I emailed a complaint to OpenTable and the response I got was that I had not showed up on time and that the restaurant had charged my credit card a fee as a result and that I should call the restaurant. I knew this was not true because I paid in cash and neither OpenTable nor the restaurant had my credit card number. Also when I called the restaurant they new nothing about this situation.
Happy with Carmella's but not with OpenTable
The Chicken Riggies were terrific!
Good meal, good cold wine and good service. Couldn't ask for more
Great place to eat and have a good time. I always like to go there when I’m home visiting family.
The riggies were mote of a wine sauce that was very nice and the lasagna was very good . 2for 1 drink specials too
Been a reliable "good feed" for decades. Waitress was a bit off her game but pleasant.
Never disappointed when we go to Carmellas! Its quiet, comfortable, friendly staff, great menu and the food is simply delicious!
Nice accommodating service. Food was prompt and very good. We enjoyed our outing with my 94 year old mom!
Great staff and food. A local Olive Garden type theme. Cannolis are fantastic. Try the pumpkin!
Italian fare is very good. The desserts are very rich. Good for a date or a family outing. Very popular, you would do well to make a reservation in advance.
Carmella's will always be our favorite! EXCELLENT food, the best sauce, bread, soups, salads. Even their coffee is the best! LOVE IT! Great atmosphere, very friendly waiters, it just has it ALL!!!!!
The food was great, and the staff was amazing!
Dish inspection- received washed but still dirty bread plates. If bread plates were not washed correctly- the dinner plates that contained our meals? Dish washing inspection a must!
Absolutely would refer a friend! Carmella’s is consistently spot on both in quality and service!
This was my first time going. It was unbelieveable. Service was amazing, the waiter was very prompt, our portions were huge!! There was not one thing bad about this place! My new favorite!!
It was a luncheon for my grandmas. The waitress was attentive and patient. The menu had something for everyone.
Great food at a reasonable price. Very good value for the money.
Great service and nice menu! Our food was tasty and delicious. We had the Utica greens which was quite different than what I am used to for greens but was very good. My daughter had the grilled herb chicken which she really enjoyed. My wife had the 1/2 rack of ribs which she said were tender and delicious. Overall it was a great find using Trip Advisor and Open Table.
While our server could not have been more professional, courteous, friendly, or competent, the hostesses left much to be desired. Three young women stood by the podium and none offered to help me for a full 6-7 minutes until I spoke up and stated I had a reservation. When the others in my party arrived they were told they could "Wander around and look" for me. It was as if the front of house was being manned by middle school girls.
Excellent waitress. Very attentive.
Was good but my potatoes were not hot and my brothers food was too tough to eat
We always love Carmella's, but the online reservation did not work. They didn't have our reservation from 'Open Table' when we arrived. Luckily they were able to accommodate us, but I will not make a reservation via Open Table online again.
The plates and wine glasses were dirty and sticky. The poor waitress was very busy and didn’t get back to our table forever. When she did she had attitude about the dirty dishes with us. We asked for extra napkins or a wet cloth. Got napkins after 4 asks.
We has an excellent meal served by a fantastic waitress. She was so friendly and gave us good recommendations. Our grilled fish was outstanding, and so was the red house wine.
Great consistent food with local favorites. Their chicken riggies are the best in the area.
Friendly staff. Because we had a reservation we were seated quickly.
The place was fun and food was really good as well.
Food was great. Atmosphere nice and wait staff was great
We were well received. Manager and server were super friendly. Our server, however, forgot to put in one of our meals. The rest of us were done eating before her meal came out if the kitchen. Our server apologized, but no restitution was made which was too bad. Food was a bit pricey for the quality.
Food was excellant..service great!....would reccomend to anyone
Awesome chicken Riggies!! My daughter is a vegetarian and loved the vegetable wrap.
My daughter’s 14th birthday dinner was excellent! Thank you!
Very tasty fun dining - enjoyed the 2 for 1 cocktail hour
Great meal,. Pizza and pasta was delicious. Our server had great recommendations and very attentive
OpenTable ダイナー54名によるCarmella's Cafeの評価は4.5☆です。