Conway Social Club
Conway Social Club tried too hard to make the club exclusive. They made us wait outside despite having reservations only to find MANY tables open. They were not accommodating for our group limiting our time with Conway Social Club. Perhaps they should try placing more focus on the people and drinks and less on the ambiance.
My sister and I was in town for medical reasons and we decided to visit this place to have a good time
Fantastic Experience! Great Food! Great Drinks! Great Service! The Best Atmosphere!
Great cocktails! There were many good cocktails to choose from.
We all loved our time there. Menu is interesting and portions are perfect. We shared everything to get a taste of lots of menu items. We’ll be back!
Cocktails are creative and good. Food was great, as always. It's a wonderful place.
Lovely place and we will return. They have done a great job of making the speak easy feel.
Food, drinks, service and ambiance were superb!
This was such a cool spot! Went here for a late valentine date with my guy and it was such a romantic feel. 1920s feel with decor and unique drinks and food. Everything tasted so good and the service was great. We were given a sample drink upon arrival. A glass of wine that I ordered was not chilled enough, so I was given a glass of champagne on the house while I waited. Will definitely be back for another date or with friends.
We love the ambiance, cocktails, and food. A speakeasy with low lighting and warmth.
Enjoyed the service, ambiance and menu.
Everything was absolutely fantastic.
I did reach out to the restaurant several times and asked for someone to call me before our reservation. I was never contacted. I was hoping to add a special touch to our experience and discuss diet restrictions. It was disappointing that no one took the time to return my phone call or email.
We enjoyed it!
Why I love sitting there: the atmosphere is dark, quiet, sophisticated, beautifully appointed, attention to detail from table to light fixtures. Why I love drinking there: they offer you a drink to sample upon arrival and there menu offers what you should be drinking that you might not find some place else. Why I love eating there: the deviled eggs and the short rib (which I was very disappointed they did not offer on my second visit) and my date LOVED the lamb but not the couscous accompaniment. Scallop dish was "eh" and the roasted vegetable dish was very nice. The service is alright. Not bad. You'll see. And of course, who doesn't love to feel like they are part of an exclusive club by being "allowed" in by the charming but a little intimidating front door attendant?
What a wonderful experience. Had a few friends meet after work and tried some delicious small plates. Atmosphere and offerings are amazing. Will be back and recommend.
I love this new place. Drinks are amazing, staff wonderful and food very good. I love the “Speakeasy” feel of the place.
Everything about this place was great. Only exception is that I made this reservation weeks in advance stating that it was our anniversary. I was hoping the hostess would have passed that note onto our server so they could have done something a little extra special that night for us.
This is a one-of-a-kind spot in Lancaster. Casual, friendly, and sophisticated, with great drinks, food, and staff. It's worth a visit, and a revisit!
Service and cocktails... go for both in an atmosphere that amplifies them well. Very nice takes on some classic cocktails that you can spot the bones of and then the house twist. We found the food uneven... small plates but still not ideal for sharing (split a single scallop anyone?). Now grated, that one scallop was purportedly the best my wife (a native New Englander) had ever had. Quail and lamb chops were good but forgettable. Cous cous side to the lamb chops was dry and distracting from the main elements. I think next time we will stick to mainly drinks (ideally a couple rounds) and the more shareable options like charcuterie or deviled eggs and plan dinner elsewhere.
We really enjoyed out first time at Conway Social Club! The small plates were very tasty and everyone really enjoyed their drinks. Fun ambiance that encourages chatting with your friends since it is not too loud. Highly recommend!
Great space, cool drinks ! Well done.
Steven, thanks so much for our review. Hope to see you again soon!
We waited 35 minutes past our reservation time in the windy, freezing cold before we were brought inside. It was another 35 minutes for drinks. It was an hour and forty five minutes past our reservation time until we got food. I had to eat NYE dinner bent over a coffee table. I expect a dinner table and real chair not a sofa. Yes, we did have all but about $60 compted, but that did not save our NYE celebration.
I'm sorry to hear about your experience at Conway Social Club. That night was our first New Year's Eve and we were trying a different style of service than what we usually provide in order to accommodate the large demand. Thank you for your feedback as it will help us provide better service in the future.