Great place to sit outdoors under overhead heaters and have a glass of rose with a friend. We've been eating here together every week since September and the staff is always welcoming and helpful. My only request would be a weekly special to give the menu some variety.
Roomy safe covid seating. Attentive server. All in our group of 4 were extremely pleased with preparation of food & quality. Prices reasonable. Wine pick surprisingly good. Will definitely return.
Great brunch! Really appreciate all the covid precautions and cleaning practices.
Server was excellent and attentive, appreciated how clean it was and available hand sanitizer. We appreciated the service and paid it forward to our server! Hope she appreciated the surprise. Will return!
Had a nice NYE dinner on the outdoor patio. The food was quite yummy, and there was something for everyone--from burgers to vegan gnocchi. Service was kind and attentive!
We have been Everly customers for many years and have always been impressed by both their food and their service--neither was remarkable on this visit, especially the service. We waited nearly ten minutes to get our first cups of coffee and nearly as long to get a refill. Audrey was pleasant, but not very attentive. She seemed to have plenty of time to chat near the kitchen although her customers were waiting for service.
We won't be returning anytime soon.
Food is delicious, and plenty of amazing vegan options. Our server was excellent and even recommended a vegan dessert - I was so happy with my whole experience!
Great outdoor patio!
Outdoor heaters made pandemic patio dining more than tolerable in December. Fantastic food and service.
We had lunch here for my daughters 21st birthday . The champagne cocktail was amazing. LOVE the gf options and dedicated gf fryer!! Our server Noah did a great job yesterday of handling the entire restaurant, take out orders as well as mixing drinks.
The burger was charred but I could tell it would have been excellent if it wasn’t burnt 😐. The rest of the meals were good but I feel they can step up the quality of the food a bit and be more careful in preparation.
I will continue to support but hope they will consider the recommendations.
I met a friend here and we had a great lunch. The patio is awesome with overhead heaters and the food was fabulous!
Outdoor seating was warm and I felt they did everything they could to make Covid safe. We liked everything but the tomato soup and we mentioned it to our waitress she didn’t offer any alternative she just said hmmm.
This was our first COVID indoor dining experience and Everly did a great job making us feel comfortable and welcome. The food was amazing and we had a great experience.
I was very impressed with how they covered the 6 feet distancing and even had a special station to sanitise
Your hands. We were greeted cheerfully and gave us plenty of time to choice from their marvellous menu.
I liked the eclectic healthy choices and drinks.
Food was wonderfully different and special and so were the non Alcoholic drinks. We came away uplifted and definitely wanting to return even though it is a two hour trip . By the way the UWArboretum is close by where we took amazing trails.
The food was delicious and the service excellent! So glad you have heaters and outdoor dining.
The pot roast was fantastic!! 😁
Just consistently churning out some of the best food in Madison. A particularly great destination during Covid-19 due to outdoor tables with overhead heaters. We’ll keep coming through the winter as long as the outdoor tables are available!
Excellent as always! Appreciate the heated patio for the colder weather.
Loved being able to sit outside with the overhead heaters within the pergola.
My friend and I dine weekly at Everly's - outside under the heat lamps when possible, and inside at a physically distanced table the rest of the time. The staff is serious about Covid precautions encouraging us to look at their menu on our smart phones v. contaminating a paper menu, and making sure that everyone is masked and using hand sanitizer. We are so grateful to be able to continue meeting at Everyly's and will do everything to support their Covid conscious dining.
Best experience I’ve ever had a restaurant ever
Fantastic! Appreciated safe, warm patio seating! Hope you stay open all winter!
Truffle fries and cocktails were good.
Everly’s does it all right. They professionally execute the safety protocols. The food is outstanding!
Small place in a little shopping center. Nice wait staff. We were there at lunch/brunch. My husband had a breakfast burrito and I had a grain bowl with tofu. Both were large servings and very tasty. Not a big selection of alcoholic drinks but ok for menu. Because of Covid-19, we would recommend a reservation due to limited seating. If we lived in Madison , we would come back.
So glad for a place where we can eat outside safely during the pandemic as the weather cools this fall! Food’s great too!
Amazing experience from start to finish. Social distancing enforced and server had us stop at ‘sanitization station’ prior to being seated. My mom and I shared a bottle of wine and the brussel sprouts as an appetizer; both were great selections. As an entree, both my mom and I each got the chicken entree which was perfectly cooked; juicy and tender on the inside with the skin crispy and the flavor was incredible. Highly recommend the shortcake for dessert. Prices were very reasonable as well; needless to say, I will be back!
The menu had a variety of food and beverage choices. The chicken and waffles are flavorful and portions generous. The same with the So Cal grain bowl. There was plenty of outdoor dining and tables were arranged with social distancing in mind. Great dining experience at reasonable prices.
I felt that the restaurant and wait staff took Covid 19 precautions seriously. I felt comfortable dining in their out door patio area. Food and drinks were good.
Really enjoyed the food and the outdoor dining setup was good.
Very safe and taking great precautions. Great service and food per usual
The burger during brunch was perfectly cooked, very delicious. Truffle fries were awesome as well.
My first time at Everly was a delight! First off, I appreciated so much the policies and guidance for COVID-19 restrictions. The sanitizing station was such a kind gesture. I loved the house-made sausage hash that I ordered for brunch. The only thing that would have made it a 5-star experience is just having my water and coffee filled up without asking. Otherwise, everyone was very kind and lovely. I will definitely be back!
They didn’t have the entree I wanted :(
Another good experience! We love eating outside at a place taking good health precautions. Food and drinks were great as always. Lots of gluten-free options.
Great food and atmosphere! Awesome cocktails and non-alcoholic options. Service was quick and friendly. One of my favorite places in Madison!
Curry and grain bowl were tasty. But added tofu was dry and cut in slim squares that just did not blend with dish. The salad dressing was all oil and flavorless. Our waitress was nice and prompt. Previous brunch was delicious. Will not be back for dinner. On positive note, the establishment provided a safe, clean, COVID responsible environment.
The food was not very good. The chicken sandwich gave my husband an upset stomach.
Quiet on a COVID-era weekday lunch. For me, that lunch was two appetizers (carrots, broccoli), both very good. Good coffee too. Good service makes three. This is on my list for next trip to Madison.
We've tried multiple times since the COVID changes, but are disappointed that the menu continues to be rather boring and the majority of our favorites are gone. Also, charging $6 for a glass of orange juice is absurd. No longer worth the drive/expense.