I dined with my wife on September 11, the chicken, sweet potato fries, shepherds pie and house salad were very good. Sidney was our server and she was outstanding.

Great evening on the patio. Food was delicious and Koral was a lovely waitress.

Great. Food

This is the 3rd time I have been here. I like the outdoor patio and the food is quite good.

Great food, ambience and service. Our server was friendly and knowledgeable, and the cost for two meals and drinks was quite reasonable. Really enjoyed our date night - we'll be going back for sure!

Only 3 tables had patrons in the whole restaurant, 2 tables with couples and ours being the largest (2 families of 4) including kids. Our order took ever an hour to arrive. We will not be back due to that reason.

Great service by Coral !

Our waitress was so friendly and attentive to our needs. The food was delicious and great portions

We come here often and have always enjoyed the food and the service. The Patio is a good size and guests have the choice of either under the roof, or out in the open.

Great experience

Had to seat ourselves. No one acknowledged us even after we were seated. Had to go to the bar to let someone know we wanted service. Bartender Crystal ended up taking care of us even though we were not drinking. Food took almost an hour to get. Overall not a good experience and we will not return

My friend finally moved back after being gone for a long time, so we decided to pick a new place we had never eaten at before and man WAS IT EVER THE BEST CHOICE! The hostess and servers are the most kindest, caring and very attentive (what more could you ask for?!) I had the cajun Salmon bowl but substituted the salmon for chicken and it was still amazing ! My friend is vegetarian and wanted to try the butter chicken with rice so they made her a veterinarian style butter chicken ! Which I though was absolutely amazing they accommodated her and her needs (which many places still don't!) this is a 12/5 star restaurant we both would recommend eating here (we booked a dinner same day) for this week, so it shows how great this environment, the staff and OBVIOUSLY the food and drinks are as well❤️❤️❤️ thank you for an amazing lunch !

Great staff great food great value and live music was great!

We really enjoy our dinner, the service was outstanding very attentive server.
Nice ambiance.

Always a wonderful meal! Great welcoming service.

Nice family dinner on the patio. Great food, highlights were the beef and mushroom bowl and the salmon bowl also really enjoyed the blarney chips. Server was warm and friendly, made for a wonderful evening.

Great service and very friendly

Food was great as always. Jacqueline was great, she was a fantastic server! Definitely going to ask for her when we come back

Our local. Always good food and atmosphere. Best patio in Newmarket

It very noticeable that the food portion is less than before

small portions for the price

Kids menu was KD straight out of the box!

Our server was awesome! Friendly and helpful. Food was awesome and quick service. Thank you will be back

Very friendly . Good and service was good. Had the Rubin and sweet potato fries very good. The Guinness steak bowl. liked it better when it is in pie form.

It was my mom’s 80th Bday and she loves Fionns so that is where we went😁 she loved it. A big thanks to our server! Sorry I can’t find my receipt to get her name. She was very polite and sweet. We had a 1:00 pm patio reservation on Saturday July 31 if that helps. Thanks again for being consistent with the food and the service!

Great service

Good food, good service in a friendly environment

We could not eat all the food we received and brought it home and it is now all consumed and enjoyed

Great service and a delicious meal. The price of my meal was high but I guess that can be expected due to the devastating economic impact of Covid19.

Server was very sweet and the food was good...just a little noisy on the patio from traffic.
I’d recommend the place.

The manager Richard is outstanding. He goes above and beyond for his customers

On this particular visit, the kitchen seemed to be struggling to keep up. We were told that tables were allotted 90 minutes, but it was close to an hour for the food to arrive. When it did, two of the orders were wrong. One was significant enough that we mentioned it to the server who immediately took it back for correction, the other was small enough we didn’t bother.

The service, however, was great all the way through. The server was diligent, pleasant, and definitely eager to correct the problem, and the manager made a point of coming over to apologize as well, offering a complimentary side while the corrected order was being finished.

After months of being closed to indoor dining and focused on delivery, I would have expected the table service to be an issue and not the kitchen, so this was unexpected. Overall, though, it’s been a rough 16 months for restaurants so I’m happy to cut them some slack. We’ll definitely be back and I’d encourage others to give them a shot as well.

Grace our server rep was so cute and pleasant

Great spot in Newmarket to enjoy a meal on the patio.

Photo of the food in the menu didn’t come close to representing the plate as served (fried chicken sandwich).

Server was pleasant and efficient.

The hostess was rude and abrupt. We were not happy with the little table up against the wall in the sun that was assigned to us. We booked our reservation three days prior yet we were told that if we wanted another table we were to be out in one hour and fifteen minutes max. When we left there were lots of empty table on the patio. I would not return to this restaurant. This was our first and last time. Too bad because it is handy for us and we thought about asking some neighbours to join us on your patio but we thought we should try it first. We were asked at the time of the reservation if we were celebrating anything and we were celebrating our anniversary. There was no special recognition for that. On the bright side our server was friendly and efficient.

Great drinks and good snacks on the patio. Quite busy but even though we arrived early, they found us a couch to hang until our table was available.

Always a great experience at Fionn MacCool’s!! Love the large vegan section of the menu!

Always a great place for my husband and i to catch the Friday fish and chips for two. Great Guinness, great food and always lovely service.

The service was impeccable with your friendly staff, as always

We enjoyed Fionn MacCools and we will be going back again.