Michael Anthony's Cucina Italiana
Espresso and rum soaked ladyfingers layered with a Mascarpone mousse and cocoa
Ravioli dell Giorno
House made ravioli of the day MARKET PRICE
Tagliatelle alla Bolognese
House made ribbon pasta with classic meat sauce of Bologna
Simply outstanding. My wife enjoyed her ravioli pasta special, while I indulged in the fresh snapper special...both dishes expertly prepared and plated. Make sure you order the dessert sampler which includes tiramisu, panna cotta and profiterole...we could not decide which one was the best but glad we got to try them all!
I took my wife out for to Michael Anthony's for date night on a early Saturday evening and the experience was top notch all the way around. Friendly hostesses, excellent servers, outstanding food, and great ambience. We had early reservations for 5:15 and we couldn't have chosen a better time to go, as it was quiet and intimate. By the time we left, around 630, it was starting to pick up of course, but I could see the servers were all over it. A manager, Ian, came around near the end of our meal to check how everything was, so that's always nice. Our main server was Johnathan, who was "Johnny on the spot", and Sam provided backup service, which was just great.
This was our first time there, and we will definitely return.
We visit the island in the Spring and Fall a drive our Fall visit to celebrate my birthday. We were greeted immediately and everyone wished me a happy birthday and made sure our evening was very special from food recommendations and wine pairings. The evening was special and so much fun!
Way overpriced. Not coming back. Tried to upcharge with wine flights but first two courses were marginal at best.
The food was excellent. The service was very professional.
Great wine pairing at the bar!
Always a wonderful meal and experience at Michael Anthony's.
Very good food and great service!! Will dine here again and will recommend it!!
Great just great.
Our waiter was awesome!!! So sweet and accommodating!!
In the age of the Pandemic, Michael Anthony's staff had spaced the tables to roughly 5- - 75% capacity. All Wait staff wore masks and our server was friendly, caring and efficient. Dinner was wonderful as always.
Great restaurant. Wonderful ambiance. Great service. Food was outstanding.
Our server, Lucy Hunter, was excellent and I highly recommend her. The meal was also amazing. I had the grouper special and my wife had the ravioli special. We will definitely go back when we are vacationing at Hilton Head.
Fabulous, romantic dining experience. We’ll be back!
One of my favorite places to eat on the island. Food is always great and meets the expectations!!
Service is also beyond reproach.
Our visit was not as expected. MA has been one of our favorites on the island, but not this night. The upstairs seating was OK - not the same as downstairs. Our wine order did not come to the table until after our meals were served and after repeated requests. The pasta seemed rather starchy and perhaps too al'dante. Just a bad night?
Anniversary dinner. Ate there twice during our short stay in Hilton Head. Food was amazing! Can’t go wrong with anything!
Nice meal, definitely pricey but good for dates/special occasions.
Really delicious high quality food and nice service.
Food was iffy.
Pasta sticky and doughy, meat ordered medium was served rare.
One diner ordered coffee, and was ignored.
Drinks were very slow to arrive.
I am not quite sure how this restaurant has the high ratings that it has other than there are probably not enough fine dining establishments in Hilton head. If rating solely on ambience service and environment then yes this is a four-star experience however the food is not. The bread that they brought to the table was over toasted it was accompanied with some kind of spread that tasted like water down hummus I ordered a fillet that had no seasoning was covered in cheese some form of cranberry sauce my husband ordered veal it was nothing spectacular and we shared a bowl of pasta Bolognese which again was nothing fantastic. Italian food is known for its rich flavor and I just did not experience any of that here. $135 later we both left there kind of meh.
Fabulous food, great environment, highly recommend.
Mixed review on the food. I had the shrimp special and it was good. My husband had a seafood pasta that was very average. Not sure if we were there on a busy night, but it took at least 45 mins to get our food. Ambience is very nice, but seemed a bit overpriced.
Nice restaurant, good ambiance, excellent staff...The food we had was nicely prepared,
tasted good, but portions seemed quite small and the bill was rather expensive for what we received. Just didn't seem worth it so we probably won't be returning there again.
Wonderful antipasto, tasteless Bolognese(sp), great service and ambience. Order something else.
Our dinner was fabulous from beginning to end. The ambiance and service was top notch and the food was amazing! Make sure to save room for the tiramisu. It’s out of this world. This Italian girl was thoroughly impressed!
Great dinner! Our dear waitress was overloaded with multiple tables but did the best she could. Excellent desserts!
Michael Anthony’s is one of our favorite restaurants when visiting the island. However, this night was a disappointment. Poor service, slow service and over cooked food. Hopefully, just a bad night! We will return and hope that is back to its usual high standard.
Food was amazing and the service was great. Would highly recommend it and be sure to make a reservation!
4th visit in 2 weeks. I had pasta with clams and my wife had the fusilloni with mushrooms and gorgonzola sauce. Housemade lemoncello at the end. Amazing, as always.
Great food, service, and atmosphere. Kat our server was excellent!
This little gem is in a building with other businesses. We almost missed it. So deceiving on the outside. We walked in to a beautiful restaurant with an ambiance unsurpassed. We felt like we were in a 5 star restaurant as soon as we entered. The staff was so professional and attentive to us. The food was outstanding. We will be retuning on our next visit to Hilton Head.
My wife and I were looking for fine dining in Hilton Head and Michael Anthony’s fit the bill. We sat at the bar and the bartenders were great and knowledgeable. Pasta was very fresh and the tiramisu was some of the best we’ve had. Highly recommend.
Veal ravioli was good. The Caprasie was small. Tiramisu was excellent.
It was our anniversary and the staff went above and beyond to give us a special night! Prosecco upon being seated, Lemonchello, and Desert with a candle!
Food was awesome and service was outstanding! Covid precautions also very thorough and tightly upheld to allow everyone to feel safe dining.
Very high quality place with a variety of food. High end ambiance also.
Great food and service. Our waiter was freindly and professional. The food was outstanding. I had fish and my wife had the pasta. Both were excellent. Salads were also very good. I had pear salad that was very nice. Nice wine selection too. This is not your typical upscale restaurant at the beach. It's much better.
It was great. Local hidden gem for out of towners
Sadly Michael Anthony’s has gone downhill. Cocktail was watered down; wanted a glass of rose’ but none available; chose a different wine, and nope it was not available; Parmesan cream sauce on the ravioli was like glue and not a garnish on the dish. It came time for dessert and all they had was tiramisu and gelato. We asked why the normal offerings were unavailable and the server replied, “Don’t know; that’s above my pay grade.” Prices were out of line for the quality of the experience. This restaurant was always our “go to” when on Hilton Head, but I doubt we will be returning. Disappointing.
Food, drink and overall ambiance was good. However, the service was really strange...not friendly, not inviting, no real dialogue on things related to the meal, the place, etc. It was the most abrupt, and disconnected of any upscale restaurant that I have experienced in a very long time. So much for Southern Hospitality.
Michael Anthony's Cucina Italianaはテイクアウトにも対応しています。テイクアウトはお電話（(843) 785-6272）でご注文ください。
OpenTable ダイナー3218名によるMichael Anthony's Cucina Italianaの評価は4.7☆です。