Jordan was an outstanding wait person. Everything was wonderful from the moment we arrived

We were seated in basement which felt very different than the upstairs where we have dined many times. Low ceilings and very somber quiet ambience. Our server was great and the food was devious as expected but I would request to be seated in the main dining room next time.

We had a very helpful server who was attentive. The food was delicious. Large servings. Well prepared. Nicely presented. We will be back. Just a note: this restaurant is byob

Another lovely evening. Dwayne is a lot of fun and always provides excellent hospitality. Fantastic truffle chicken special. Calamari always one of our favorites. The chocolate peanut butter bomb was ridiculously delicious. See you folks again soon!

Food was excellent

Have been here 5 or 6 times now and always get a great meal. We had Cassie as our server last 2 times, she does an excellent job!

Excellent and accommodating, prompt seating, good distancing.

Panico’s is a place we like for occasions, always feels special. Food and service are always good,

Food is always great here byob clean and staff is masked all the time. Dwayne was excellent and funny he made our night complete. Always a great stop.

Family Easter dinner - great food - service was fast!

Amazing food and friendly service. It was our first time and we will definitely come back. Thank you

A fun place to go with a group or as a couple. I was impressed with the octopus appetizer. It was cooked perfectly!
Go hungry, as the homemade bread they serve to your table is a meal onto itself.

The veal dinner special was outstanding

Wonderful little restaurant!

Great value, excellent food and love the atmosphere!

I just love this restaurant! Our waiter Max was amazing he was very attentive . Our apps and entrees were timed perfectly!! The food here is delicious and well prepared and garnished. The bread is unbelievable!! Great place to dine and relax.

Best meal we've had in recent memory! Glad we came. We will be back with friends and family.

Saturday night
Seated quickly and waitress stopped by within a few minutes. Brought back beer glasses and reviewed the specials available.
Ordered appetizers and gave us plenty of time before taking the dinner order. Food was excellent as usual and Terri is a great server. Homemade bread is a wonderful bonus on any night.

We love Panico’s. Every time we visit Cape May we make sure we dine here. The food is always scrumptious. This visit Jordan our server was very professional as well friendly. We’ll be back in May.

Seated in the basement....they have a basement? Waiter was delightful. Food was very good. Maybe I would have preferred upstairs but overall it was worth it

Great food, good service we just love it there.

We got seated in the basement. Should have asked us if we would prefer the main dining room.

Best food ever! Eggplant dish is always a favorite, along with the mozzarella fritto appetizer, 3 cheese chicken & the pizzas! The bread, sauce & cheese in the dishes are fantastic.

Great place!!! Bread was the best ever!!

Wonderful food and service

Dinner with my husband! Connor our waiter was exceptional and personable!

Loved the setting, very cute. Food was delicious and portions huge. The wood oven pizza was phenomenal, as was everything else. Donut filled with ice cream for dessert couldn't be beaten!

Great new find for us in Cape May Area of Southern New JErsey, we will certainly add them to our list of favorite restaurant to go to.
The service was great, the food was great
We were in the Lounge (basement of the Church) that did not matter, we are looking forward to a return trip to sit upstairs in the actual church, but either way the atmosphere, food and service was outstanding.

The Food was authentic, delicious and hearty portions sizes. Fantastic value for the price of entrees (moderate), beautiful lighting and ambiance, without squinting to see my food! BYOB keeps the price down, and the service was great. definitely going back!

We had a great meal and service. Next time prefer to be on the main level vs. the basement.

our waitress was amazing. Over an above and the sweetest person and made our birthdays special

Man do I love that Osso Buco! Everything worked out perfectly with seating, dinner, and desert. Thanks for another awesome meal :)

Amazing quality food, huge portions and lovely server Jordan.

Panicos is amazing. Our Veal Meal with Pears was delicious. The clam pizza is our favorite. The service was excellent. Great atmosphere ! One of our favorite places.

Basement seating takes away from the awesome ambience that Panico always has

We came here for a combined Valentine's Day/Birthday Dinner celebration. We were seated immediately and greeted by our waitress not long after that. The food came out in a timely manner. We enjoyed our meal immensely.

This was my first time eating here and it was fabulous! They started us out with bread, which was fabulous. The mussels and sauce were amazing as well as our meals. Their red sauce is the best I've had in years!

Celebrating my husbands 50th he and I . We had a waiter Connor, it was his first night, he was very attentive, knew the menu and was professional. He did a great job. This was our first time eating indoors there loved it. ALWAYS great food there. Highly recommend. Thanks

Very pleasant wait staff, delicious food and great atmosphere. Hats off to the chef for the best meal in Cape May. My son was so impressed. Thank you!!

Mini weekend away. The meal was awesome. The quantity and quality was more than we expected. Serving would have fed two people. Would definitely go again. Our waitress was very personable. I am finicky but would say one of the best places I ever ate.