Third time coming this summer. Makenzie is amazing!!!
Great experience it was our first visit to the restaurant. The sweet and sour calamari was fantastic! The halibut was great too with a very unique preparation. Mackenzie was an attentive and entertaining server. Will definitely be back.
The food was mediocre. Way below expectations. Nice room, service was fine.
Great place for a girls’ night out with friends! Food and service were excellent. Our only (mild) complaint was our party of 6 of ladies who are 50+ being seated at a high top table, but the delicious drinks got us over the issue quickly.
After a terrible start at another venue (a shaken Manhattan is a hard WTF??!! in my book), we arrived at Pilgrim House to a warm, cozy setting, an excellent barkeep, and a charming waiter that helped us have a thoroughly enjoyable evening. Will absolutely visit again. Thank you Mackenzie and P.H.!
The food was just fantastic. Totally recommend the calamari appetizer, shrimp and grits and the halibut. The lemon, blueberry cheesecake was a very nice finish to a fantastic meal. If you are in Provincetown, you must try the Pilgrim House!
Great place without/with children, flat breads and fries, fish and chips (delicious), and others, nice drink options.
Very good meal (the soups especially were amazing), we were just disappointed with the scallop risotto. Scallops were great but the risotto itself was bland. It was still a great meal but the risotto better be impressive if you’re going to charge $36 for 4 scallops.
Service was excellent and in the world of Covid I still felt safe eating here (outside).
Great service, nice atmosphere, good drinks.
Seemed to be following covid safety requirements.
Incredible meal! The Brussels sprouts were perfectly cooked and the cheesecake was the best we’ve ever had! We can’t wait to return!
The food looked lovely and was fresh, but lacked flavor. I appreciate food that isn't salty, but unless I added salt, there was really very little flavor.
We had great s
LOVE the lemon ginger martini! And the flatbread an Brussel sprouts. Sat outside....Covid. Heat lamps kept us warm and our server was excellent. Went twice in one week!
nice spot. excellent service made the night very nice.
McKenzie was fantastic, the drinks were good but other than the calamari the food left a lot to be desired. It was my 30th birthday and we were seeing Paige turner — nothing was done for my birthday even though both the server and the host said happy birthday to me. Quite disappointed. Not to mention it ended up being quite expensive, for food that was the same quality as chili’s.
Service was spot on! Very attentive, nicely spread out. Cocktails were created and consistent, food was cooked and presented for all senses to enjoy!
The setting is refreshing with updated decor similar to mid-high level hotels. Service was great (like many reviewers we had Merlot) and food arrived in just the right amount of time. The sweet potato kale soup and clam chowder are excellent. Flat breads are rather large so order accordingly. I had the fish tacos and I would strongly suggest changing the tortillas to corn. I’ve never had fish tacos on flour tortillas and they made the contents taste dry.
Merlot, our server, is lovely. Food is good too esp the Shrimp and Grits.
Beautiful location, great outdoor dining, excellent service and who knew Gouda grits in Yankee territory could be the best I ever had?
Food was ok but expensive. Was overall a disappointment. Service may have been mediocre due to COVID
Food prep took a long time - not sure why. Not all that busy. Server was fine but service overall not good. Three orders of short ribs tasted very good. Halibut was dry and had obviously even sitting for a while prior to serving - was not hot - crispy onion topping was not crispy - a bit soggy. Sauce was a bit coagulated. Would try again.
Absolutely fabulous from start to finish. Our server Merlot was amazing and the food was delicious. Can’t wait till next time!
Great food, felt safe with tables 12’ or more away from each other. MacKenzie was a great server. Will definitely recommend and return!
This hotel restaurant is above average for virtually all considerations, but don’t expect more. It is highly satisfactory. Zero complaints.
Located back from Commercial Street, it offers a quiet and delightful modern setting. The charm ends there as it is average otherwise. While I would return, it would be because my “A” list restaurants were booked.
I took into account the pandemic before reviewing. The restaurant is clean and inviting. The ambience is great. The location on the Harbor adds to the likability of this venue. Pleasantly greeted. Sat promptly. Followed good protocols. We were required to order everything at once. There is no opportunity for a cocktail and an appetizer, the minimum compliance with state law, and was pushed to order everything immediately. Understandable. The menu was flush with good options. I chose the wedge salad as my appetizer-with-main. Salad was fresh and clean. Properly chilled. Overall, good experience. Good food. I will come back again after the pandemic is over.
The food was awesome, service was excellent and eating outside was perfect. Even if there were no pandemic, I would opt to be outside. Cape Cod fresh air!
Everything was great but only critique would be that the short ribs were very dry. Besides that, dinner was delicious and service was amazing. Loved the shrimp and grits!
Awesome food and service at the restaurant. We had the halibut and short ribs. Both to die for. Perfectly cooked. Sweet potato purée soup was delicious but would’ve loved something to dip with and they skimped on the chorizo. Merlot was our charming server and the table outside on the upper deck was perfect. We made reservations a day before and were super pleased.
Service was slow and inconsistent. Food was average at best
Great place to eat and relax! McKenzie is super
Wonderful experience made exceptional by their new chef Christopher. We have been back many times this year.
It was wonderful. We had a high top table inside; the lighting was perfect. We had wedge salads that were Delish. For dinner we had the ribs, halibut, sea bass and scallops. Everyone was very pleased w their selection. For desert we split the bread pudding. The chef came out to see how we liked our meal and he was so friendly. I will definitely eat there again when I am in P-Town.
Fun, and great food.
Decent entrees, great service, just didn’t knock our socks off, it was average fair!
Well done. Excellent food and service. Kudos to McKinsey for making it look effortless in a mask. Loved the chowder. Will be back.
StevenW, Thank-you for the high marks and the kind recognition of our spectacular team. Mackenzie is the all-star leader of our year-round service team that takes great pride in earning the WOW from every one of our guests. Mackenzie makes getting that wow look easy, even in a mask! Alos, I happen to agree with you about our clam chowder - best in town, made fresh in house by Chef Thames and his amazing culinary team. We all look forward to your return. Happy Labor Day - Ken Horgan, Owner
Food was very salty. Jumbo shrimp were tiny. When brought the attention. It was not well received and no apology issued.
Waiter served wrong drinks and clueless.
Would not recommend and not go back.
Thanks for taking the time to provide feedback. We're always looking to improve & sincerely want to see reviews from all guests! Your review reminds us, we MUST get it right every time for every guest. It's been years since we've seen FOOD-1 star / SERVICE-2 stars. I hope to change your mind, get you to return & let us show you - we DO have the 5 star food & service highlighted in our reviews. Our entire PH team share your disappointment! I hope to hear from you. Ken Horgan, Owner (508) 487-6424
Covid compliant. Food and service was wonderful. We will definitely go back!
We are proud of our entire Pilgrim House team in the way they are responding to all of the additional steps necessary to keep everyone safe during this difficult time. We are looking forward to your return soon. Thanks for the feedback. Happy Labor Day!
The service was excellent and we enjoyed each and every meal! The setting was very unique and safe and we met the chef which was a delight!
Excellent experience - food was superb, Chef James has done a great job with the menu!
This is the place to go, really amazing simple food, great atmosphere and service
Pilgrim Houseはテイクアウトにも対応しています。テイクアウトはお電話（(508) 487-6424 ext. 2）でご注文ください。
OpenTable ダイナー139名によるPilgrim Houseの評価は4.6☆です。