Prime 957 Steakhouse
The food is excellent and a great value for a steakhouse. Everyone's meals were delicious, the service was excellent and it was an overall excellent experience. We will go back. The owner, Christian is friendly and personable as is the entire staff!
It was very good but we feel they were overpriced especially when you’re having pasta as a special with some lobster meat in it $29 is a bit high
The food, the drinks and the service, all outstanding. We started with the Crab cakes, very delicious. For the main course we had the Maine Wild Salmon, it was cooked to perfection. The Lava cake and Carrot cake was the perfect ending to a wonderful evening. I highly recommend this restaurant, I look forward to my next visit, I know it will be excellent.
Went here for a Valentine’s Day dinner and the food was great. The staff was very friendly and owner/manager came over to us towards the end of meal to check in and make sure everything good.
Very accommodating host and staff. It was a lovely dining experience for our Valentine's Day celevration. The rose presented to the ladies as they left was a very nice touch. Very good food. We will be back!
The food was excellent, the service was excellent and the atmosphere was excellent. A++++
I have been looking for a restaurant with excellent signature drinks and an exciting menu. Prime delivered. I had a warm mushroom salad with steak and exquisite cocktail. My new favorite in Mahopac!
We had heard that the steaks were excellent so being steak people, we wanted to try it out. My daughter and I shared the 40 ounce Tomahawk served with mushrooms and Brussels sprouts. This was excellent. Another daughter had the lamb chops and my wife had a grilled salmon dish. Everyone enjoyed their meals. I have paid more for a large steak and not enjoyed it as much. We are likely to return too.
We went for my wife’s birthday, and were pleasantly surprised. The service was excellent, everyone was friendly and the staff was quite knowledgeable. Christian (the owner) stopped by and really wanted to know how our meal was, gave me a background on my dish (short rib meatloaf) that was from his grandmother. Exceptional meal. We will definitely go back.
Great selection of food. Personal service. Owner checking in to make sure everything is good.
Food and service were fantastic - highly recommend!
We went on a Thu night at 7 for a birthday dinner. They were prepared for my long list of allergies and happily accommodated. The tomahawk steak special for 2 was amazing. I had two more dinners as leftovers! Service was spot on, drinks were great and the whole experience was as it should be for a nice occasion. Can’t wait to return.
Excellent food. Steak was perfect. Good value
Excellent food, service and value. The grilled oysters melt in your mouth. Steaks cooked to perfection. Highly recommend! Will definitely return!
Been here several times. Friendly staff, great quality and reasonably priced.
It was a wonderful birthday experience! The food was fabulous and the waitstaff were a wonderful addition to our dining experience.
Finally an actual great local restaurant. Food was phenomenal. Service was top notch, and what made things even better was knowing the owner is originally from the Bronx just like us. Too bad it took us this long to even know this place was open. So many steps up from the previous spot that was located here and doesn’t even compare to the Sizzler on the other side of town. We started with a couple of their specialty cocktails, yea you have to try the Rosemary one and the Soul one. They said all American here and were surprised to see the Tagliatelle special. Let me tell you that dish was one of the best I’ve ever had and they aren’t even trying to be Italian. We also had the Crab cakes, Gator, Chicken fried Steak, and the Cowgirl. Everything was cooked perfectly. Even the mashed potatoes and broccoli were amazing. Bottle of OVR with dinner and after didn't have room for dessert but we enjoyed a bourbon cream, hot buttered rum and a ridiculous chocolate martini and after the owner gave us a taste of his homemade eggnog. It was RIDICULOUS!! We’ll definitely be back and recommend it to all our friends and family. Worth every single penny!!
We dined on a Thursday night after Christmas and the dinning room was vert quite, maybe one other table was occupied at 7:30pm. The owner seated us and the entire staff was very friendly and attentive. We all enjoyed our appetizers and entrees. The steak was excellent and very flavorful. I would recommend this restaurant and look forward to returning.
So delicious and fresh. The seasoning was perfect and the cut of meat was top grade. The server was kind and had attention to detail. We went last year to another local steak house for Christmas Eve and were not impressed nor was the service good.
This restaurant, now under NEW OWNERSHIP, is in the location of the old Chophouse restaurant in Mahopac. The new owner, a long time restaurateur, has created a much upgraded experience. The menu is best described as “American”. My wife and I tend to split things, so we each had a chopped wedge salad - we should have split that, it was huge - then we split a pasta with a bolognese sauce, topped with burrata, excellent, then we split a filet, perfectly cooked medium with vegetables. We added a side of mushrooms, not on the menu, but you can ask. The wine list was mostly made up of wines I had never heard of, but Christian, the owner, suggested Ramey, which turned out to be an nice gentle cab. Definitely a place we will return to.
Christmas Eve dinner
We celebrated Christmas Eve at this restaurant. The food was amazing! I had the Filet Oscar and it was so delicious. What a nice time we had. The service really was the best part - the wait staff and owner were super attentive. We really enjoyed ourselves and I am happy we found a new place! Can't wait to go back :)
Out party of 6 had a great time ... food, drink, and great fun friendly service ... we will be back
Our first visit and it didn’t disappoint. We frequented the prior establishment Chophouse so we were hoping it was comparable and it was. There were four of us and had various dishes like short rib meatloaf, strip steak and burgerS. All were delicious. The service was excellent and attentive. We’re going back
If you’re a true foodie, this is the spot for you. Shared the Alabama wings and the special tomahawk. Cocktails were on point and loved the huge bourbon list. Service was extremely helpful especially with the all American concept. Try and save room for dessert because the portions are big. Definitely try this place. We’ll be back
First time visiting since they opened and was very impressed and happy to have a steakhouse of this caliber in our neighborhood. Chill vibe paired with outstanding food and great service. Will return again soon....
Amazing place ! Menu is awesome - we had a great dinner and look forward to goi back soon
Food was absolutely delicious. Steaks cooked perfectly and crab cake was amazing. Service was great. Highly recommend, definitely will be back.
Was very satisfied with Prime 957. As soon as we walked i we were greeted cheerfully by the owner. This was our 1st time here, and immediately felt like family. Our server, Phoenix was so courteous and cheerful. Food was plentiful and delicious. The bread that serve is the best bread I have ever tasted. Yes, bread! The softest buttery bread ever!
We were so thrilled with our 1st visit here, we came back again last night for more. Again, great food, service and hospitality.
I highly recommend Prime 957.
Exceptional. Steaks were great quality. Very intriguing cocktail and liquor list. We can’t wait to come back. Definitely a hidden gem. Best of luck to the new owners.