Great dinning experiences in a beautiful setting overlooking the harbor.
Ambiance was lovely, food was delicious, although I wish there were a few more choices for the non seafood lovers in my party.
Food was great. Waitress was so nice! We highly recommend.
Beautiful location - lovely outdoor dining - our server was "ok" - very pricey -
Good for a special ocasion
Perfect in every way! Amazing setting, delicious food, all to perfection!
We went to Showfish for our 40th Anniversary. It was our first time eating out at a restaurant since COVID. They had the incorrect time for our reservation that we made on Open Table which didn’t start things off too well.
The food was wonderful. The scallops were delicious. However, The service needs improvement. The waiter forgot about my drink until after we finished dinner, never told us the specials- we heard him tell another table about the Bronzino special (definitely would have ordered) after we finished our dinner.
Despite the glitches, would definitely try it again for the food and ambiance.
Delightful! Waitress Wally remembered us... what a great feeling!
Food is delicious and innovative!
Handling Covid precautions very well, masks , gloves, distance ! Food amazing and original! Service impeccable ! My favorite place to eat dinner in MTK !
Great food, atmosphere and service. Great steak....and halibut
Wonderful restaurant and best roast chicken I ever had with the tastiest au jus, mushrooms and crisp moist chicken. Delicious
The food was delicious. We had the heirloom tomato salad and shrimp cocktail for appetizer . The tomatoes were from local farms it was so fresh and wonderful. The shrimp were huge and also delicious. The entree we went with the recommendation of waiter and had the tuna steak. It was seared to perfection the best tuna I ever had. The side we went with the lobster and rice and would highly recommend it. The service was impeccable. We will definitely be going back when we visit Montauk
Gorgeous location with plenty of outdoor seating. Food is great although my chicken was dry. Pricey but are most of the better restaurants in Montauk.
Food was excellent. Filet mignon was outstanding.. appetizers were delicious from oysters to beet salad.. however our waitress was awful. Wasn’t attentive and not very personable. Would I go back? For the food I would definitely give it another try and hopefully have a different server.
Fabulous food! Sat outside and loved it. Service could be a bit more attentive.
Best dinner all week
Lack of service. It wasn’t bad...weren’t told the specials (the other tables were)...wasn’t asked if we wanted more wine...after the entrees didn’t come back to check in
Very nice outdoor table overlooking the water. It started to rain a bit and the staff was quick to either set-up patio umbrellas or relocate people indoor. One of the larger indoor spaces seemed a bit barren due to the social distancing measures.
The seafood tower was terrific...whole steamed lobster, four colossal shrimp, a dozen oysters and dozen clams. The filet mignon was cooked perfectly.
Service was personable but dropped off a bit toward the end of the meal.
Overall very good and plan on returning.
Food entrees very good $40 and over
Wine by the glass not worth it
$18 and they served one inch of wine
Cost of a bottle of wine in the store
$13 they are charging $75
Bread was stale, vegetables were not cooked (zucchini/squash), food was room temperature. Ambience and staff were great. Meal was borderline terrible.
Excellent , food was very good, staff wonderful
Our server Yamelette was exceptional.
wonderful seafood, knowledgable server, great view!
Fantastic meal! Beautiful ambiance!
This restaurant is definitely a five star restaurant located on the water in Montauk. Ambience is perfect, very romantic. Great place for couples. On the pricey side, but well worth it so don't really recommend bringing children.
A gorgeous evening with delicious food. Their childrens portions were huge. Scallops were delicious. I regret not trying the lobster kimchi fried rice. Stunning location
Food is amazing but pricey. Plenty of outside seating. Fabulous service. Great for a large gathering or intimate table of two. Special evening. Wally the waiter was awesome. Going back this month.
Beautiful at place to have a nice romantic dinner .
We loved this place. Food was good fresh and delicious.
Love it here
Great place for special occasions! On Lake Montauk with a pretty view of the marina. The prices are expensive but the quality and taste of the food were superb. The tables are social distanced according to code. It was raining the night we dined but they had a ballroom that they were able to accommodate the outside diners. I recommend the scallops and the ny strip steak. Both were cooked to perfection. Definitely a cool vibe to the restaurant.
Truly one of the better meals I’ve had in a long time.
Incredible atmosphere and incredible food. Best restaurant in MTK and it’s not even close...
Outstanding mean in a special location/views!
Great experience, excellent food, venue and service. One of the very best places in the Hamptons.
This was easily the best meal I've had on the east end of Long Island. We sat outside on a beautiful night under the stars. The service throughout the meal was impeccable. I'm glad we had the opportunity to dine here.
Shhh! This restaurant is beautifully located, professionally run and the menu and the food are the best that my wife and I have experienced anywhere in Montauk. The appetizer of soft shell crabs, the Caesar salad, my wife’s Striped Bass and finally the aged steak that might have been the best steak that I’ve ever had. Finished with Sorbet which shouldn’t be overlooked. I would love to keep this gem a secret but they deserve all the business that comes their way. Hats off to the Chef and whoever designed the space. Wonderful dining experience. We made a reservation for 3 days later on our way out.
Showfish is an incredible restaurant. Everything start to finish was just perfect. Our meal was incredible. Being a fancy restaurant, of course the prices for everything were super expensive. But that’s known at a special place like this.
We had a reservation we were given a table by the kitchen we asked for a table away from a speaker and were told it was reserved? Waited quite awhile for menus and drink orders....food was amazing but after the way we were treated don’t think we would go back
Very Good Resturant .Would go back again. meal was excellent
The food was amazing! I would definitely visit Showfish again!