St. Paul Fish Company - Mequon
Consistently good food and service! Nice atmosphere conducive to dinner conversation even with large group.
First time at this location; food was delicious, shark bite appetizer great
Food was fabulous! Eunice was attentive and friendly! Thank you!!
We really enjoyed our meal at St. Paul. It’s a great place!
No one would believe a seafood restaurant could be so popular and so excellent from the kitchen. The decor and architecture of the place is interesting, but the NOISE LEVEL IS DEAFINING! It undermined the enjoyment of the evening—however—the food was truly excellent and the kitchen staff and general manager deserve a lot of credit for making such a busy place work so well. Please hire an acoustic engineer!!
This is one of our favorite places!
The King Crab Legs (a special on Wednesdays for $20) was excellent. They give you a shell cracker and a scissors (which worked for me) but my son wished they had split the legs before serving.
My SPECIAL favorite is the Calamari Steak. It's listed as an appetizer but I like to order it as an entree. It's coated in crunchy Parmesan and is deliciously tender with a fabulous flavor. Before St Paul Fish Co you could only get this dish at the River Lane Inn in Brown Deer (before it closed) or at Timmer's Resort.
Next time I'm going to order the fried clams. I heard they are as good as the clams they used to serve at Howard Johnson's in the old days.
SO glad I am now able to make reservations using Open Table. When they first opened you had to stand in line for an hour to get a table.
One thing though - it is REALLY loud. Don't go there if you want to have an intimate conversation with your table mates.
Already told my friends(and enemies) to frequent this place. I did enjoy my experience there . I shall return.
It was very good food and a good place eat all types of seafood. I would go there again. If going on a Friday I would make a Reservation because of Lent. It was a little loud in the restaurant but it was also very busy due to being a Friday for Lent and my Wife and I expected that. The Mako Shark was very good and so was the King crab legs.
Enjoyed the fresh fish in a great environment. Mequon has become much more lively and its refreshing to have restaurants like St Paul Fish Company be a part of the community. The only suggestion is that they upgrade from plastic plates to real china and perhaps upgrade the flatware as well. On the other hand, maybe that was intentionally a part of the decor?
My husband and I love this restaurant. We moved here from Boston @ 5 years ago and were in search of great seafood. Since discovering St. Paul's, we eat here a couple of times a month. We love it!
Excellent - Brien our host was very efficient and attentive and made our visit anxious to repeat!
Reservations are a good move on a Friday night during the Lenten Season! We had a drink at the bar. The bartender was very friendly and knowledgeable. Our dinner was delicious and the service was great. (I had the mahi mahi.) I will certainly go back.
The food has been good each time we have been there (many times) but we would like something other than rice or french fries. i.e. potato wedges, baked potato, etc.
2 of 4 meals were excellent and the other 2 were good, need to keep the fries crispy and make sure the shrimp don't clump together. It was busy, service was ok. Going on slower nights ALWAYS recommend.
(...) good time ! I really recommend for everyday dining. 😋
The food was good. The server was attentive and nice. The food was very good. Some of the prices were high for what you get.
We went for the crab legs special & were not disappointed! The crabs were fresh & delicious, we’re already looking forward to going back again!
First time here, sausage and gumbo soup was delicious as was the walleye pike dinner. Thanks to our server Tyler who helped my wife deconstruct her whole lobster which she devoured. Great value and Tyler went way above the call of duty. We’ll be back many more times!
The food was excellent. Service was quick and the employees were all very friendly and courteous. It was overall a really great experience. Even my 92 year old mother, who is not easily impressed by restaurants, wants to go back.
The fish market area was fabulous as well. Great place to eat, great place to buy your seafood to bring home and cook.
Our first time at St Paul Fish company was a good one. Excellent fresh fish dishes.
SPFC has a friendly wait staff and we were seated immediately per our reservation on OpenTable during a very busy part of Friday evening dinner hour.
Good was great!
Great! Loved the place. First time experience
I had a great meal, enjoyed the atmosphere and best of all, the key lime pie!
The food was excellent, as always. I especially love the atmosphere. Our waitress was friendly and she did an excellent job.
Great food at affordable prices. Fast and professional service.
1st visit. Wife and I loved our food. I had Atlantic salmon and she had the lobster role. Fun decor too
Probably not. I have been there 2 times and had the same meal with different outcomes.
This is one of the better seafood restaurants in Milwaukee. Everything was fresh and delicious.
Tables are crowded together, not a place to sit and enjoy Valentine's Day. Food was good.
Lobster roll is awesome. Also had the mussels, which may be the best value in Milwaukee. Service was just ok.
Fast service, good food
I had the special King Salmon. It might be some of the best salmon, I have ever had. Kudos to our waiter, Jade, for suggesting it!
The food at St. Paul Fish Company was excellent. We started with crab cakes, went to Lobster bisque and finished with Lobster Rolls. Everything was served hot and everything was very tasty. The ambiance of the restaurant was nice; but the noise level was way too loud. We had to practically yell at each other to be heard. The other issue was both the hostess and the server were young and appeared to be inexperienced. We had a reservation and initially the hostess was going to seat us right away; but something happened (?) and she sent us to the bar. We then had to wait a half hour before being seated and I had to go ask her if she had forgotten us. Our server was pleasant; but we didn't see much of him. When our check arrived it was wrong. Two items were left off the check. I called it to his attention and he just said that's OK. He said he'd give it to us for free because he wasn't too attentive. I don't know if he was being courteous or too lazy to redo the check. Even with the problems, we'll be back because of the great food.
Had a very enjoyable evening with friends. Awesome food, and our waiter was spot on and great fun. Always a pleasure at St. Paul and we will be back!
Food and service were excellent! Had the Grouper fry it was fresh and tasty cooked correctly.
Service was excellent. Food was good. Place is noisy.
Very noisy and the seating was less than cozy and private... The waitress knew about 1/2 of the menu in a hurry... The odor permeated my clothing, so all that had to be cleaned.... not a good experience..
We had a party of 9 there on Friday night. They accommodated us very nicely. Food was delicious and we didn't feel rushed. Great atmosphere.
Would only return for apps
St. Paul Fish Company - Mequonはテイクアウトにも対応しています。テイクアウトはお電話（(262) 200-9909）でご注文ください。
OpenTable ダイナー42名によるSt. Paul Fish Company - Mequonの評価は4.6☆です。