The Pool Club at Gurney’s Star Island
I made a reservation several weeks before our visit. The night of our reservation Gurneys closed the Pool Club Restaurant and never let me know. I found out upon arrival after confirming via email the day prior. They offered us a seat at their upscale restaurant, however, my two young sons wanted burgers which are only on the pool club menu. The manger wouldn't accommodate us with burgers which I thought was terrible after they didn't even let us know they cancelled our reservation. We opted to take out from the take-out restaurant where they serve burgers. We ate at the Pool Club tables, the food was good. I recommend the pizza. The views are spectacular! Customer service, not so much.
We have eaten well at the main restaurant at Gurney's Star Island, so we figured that the Pool Club would be a safe bet. Our son asked for grilled chicken with his Caesar Salad. The waiter said, "Fine, fine," but then the salad came without the chicken. So we asked the waiter to please get him some grilled chicken. Nothing came. Finally another server had to get it for us. We were not amused. Pinot Noir by the glass was undrinkable. No desserts available. Is that a way to move tables faster? I don't know. They did comp us for the Chicken Caesar and the bad glass of wine, but we have absolutely no intention of ever going back. There are just too many way better choices out there. The only good thing that I have to say is that it is a lovely setting.
This met all our expectations. Great energy and ambiance. Romantic setting near the yacht harbor and excellent service and food. The choices on the menus were creative and exciting.
Great view except for the yachts with Trump flags!
The pool club at gurney‘s star Island is a gorgeous setting to have dinner at. The service was wonderful. The food was delicious and the cocktails were creative. My only complaint is that the hedges were too tall where we were sitting so we didn’t have a good view of the marina.
Great for families. Great service. Expensive. Food is average.
Beautiful water front setting, amazing service. Food was good!
Horribly overpriced for average to below average food.
Very nice outdoor dining experience - and good good and service.
We had a beautiful evening out on the water. The staff knew that we were celebrating the legacy of my mother and contributed so fully to that experience. We plan to return many times for the food, ambience, and hospitality. Thank you, Gurney!
We actually went twice during our 4 nights in Montauk because it was so wonderful. Brittany the hostess was so accommodating both nights for our large family. She’s the perfect person for initial contact at this restaurant. The food, atmosphere and service was also outstanding. It felt so nice to have a proper restaurant experience again.
Everything was tasty, especially smoked fish chowder. Our waiter, Eugene was very friendly and efficient.
Prices are too high, in particular, can of beer is $9. Open Table lists this place as inexpensive with two dollars sign. Not really!
Food was great. Wait staff was overwhelmed. Felt like I was having plates thrown at me. Killed the thrill of dinning out.
The service was good in beginning, then took forever to get check. Food was fine. Cocktails were truly horrible. I live there and understand Hamptons pricing, but still expect quality to warrant it. This did not. It was super casual bar food at the same price of other very nice Hamptons restaurants. They need to get their act together. Even if they just figure out how to make their own signature cocktails from their menu or a basic margarita I would have given it a higher rating.
It took forever for anyone to come over to us after about 3 waitresses were just staring at us from far for 15 minutes. We came to check out the hotel by having breakfast there. We always stay at Gurneys Montauk and will continue to have breakfast there.
Service was horrible!!!
Overpriced and overrated!!
OpenTable ダイナー17名によるThe Pool Club at Gurney’s Star Islandの評価は4.5☆です。