The Red Mill Inn
Cute little restaurant. Unfortunately the meal we had, which was the daily ravioli, was almost inedible. It was a butternut squash ravioli and when I asked what type of sauce the server just said it was a butternut squash sauce. Turns out it was alfredo-based and very heavy. If I had known that I would not have ordered it. Also, there was almost a cup of sauce in my bowl and the flavor of the ravioli was lost. Very unappetizing. Should have stuck to pizza or something simple.
Great food and service. We always enjoy our time there.
Sat at the bar and enjoyed a very good salad and thin crust pizza. Would return for the pizza as I really like the cracker thin crust. Toppings were generous. Good service.
Excellent pizza and garlic bread. Highly recommend.
Only my daughter and I would order a fish dry at a pizza place, but shoot was it good! The batter was airy and crispy, the cod was firm, cooked to perfection and not fishy in the slightest. I really enjoyed the potato pancakes and my daughter loved the fries. My husband had both the clay chowder as well as our favorite pizza combo - pepperoni and pepperoncini. Also did not disappoint. Our server was a bit forgetful and frazzled but managed to get thru it. There maybe an issue with the dishwasher as this was the 2nd time we were presented with dirty plates and had to send them back...so just take a peek at them before you dish out your meals. Red Mill is our favorite pizza and now fish fry spot.
Best pizza I’ve ever eaten!
Margherita pizza was delicious. Crust was homemade and thin and crisp, just the way I like it. Garlic bread was outstanding as well, and the marinara was flavorful. We will definitely be back.
We ordered garlic bread, fired mozzarella and a large cheese, sausage, mushroom and onion pizza. Out of this world delicious. Our server was on her game. I think my family may have found our new favorite pizza place!
The Pizza was great and service was very attentive
Nice friendly people and great food!
Very clean and service was great. We’ll be back!
Always good at the Red Mill Inn and we love the historical feeling and the building - very nice and friendly atmosphere too.
Service was great. Very friendly and helpful. Food was OK. A number of us ordered lasagna. It looked like a pile of noodles covered in massive amounts of sauce. Temperature of food was luke warm but we didn't want it heated up any more as noodles already were over cooked.
Good pizza & garlic bread! Would go back for sure!
Not overly impressed by the food at all. Garlic bread had no garlic taste at all, and was very blah tasting. We’re not planning to dine there again.
Best pizza we have had in quite awhile
Disappointed after frequenting this restaurant when it was Butch’s Red Mill. There were four of us and two people got their meals 10 minutes before the pizza was ready for the other two guests. There was a $3 up charge when a drink was ordered without ice (and this wasn’t even shared when the drink order was placed!). When asked about what the $3 up charge was for, the waitress (who never gave her name) seemed embarrassed to tell us saying she just learned of it herself.
We won’t be going back.
The pizza and pasta dishes were very good...if you like thin crust pizza, this is the place. Busy night but service was attentive. Only minor complaint was the cocktails could have been a bit larger, but the beer selections made up for short drinks....we will be back soon....It is nice to see the crowd and energy return to the Red Mill....
We had a GREAT experience! Great food, super service, fun place!!!
Mozzarella sticks were really good. Cheese stretched far! Ordered the spaghetti. It was good. I thought it had a little too much sauce. Service was excellent.
My husband and I Went to red mill inn for a fish fry. Our meal was wonderful, drinks and service were outstanding. We highly recommend!
Our 2nd time at the newly reopened place. First time we had pizza that was superb! This time, my lasagna was 80% sausages and hardly any pasta in it, so very mediocre. Cesear salad and garlic bread are very tasty. Is a nice cozy restaurant and we will be back, but will order the pizza!!
Awesome we will be back. We Had a group of friends that came out to eat the owner came up to us and asked how the meal wise he’s very nice. Food was great and great prices very nice atmosphere.
First time there and even though they were short 2 waitresses the service and the food was perfect!! We'll definitely go back!!!
The Red Mill Innはテイクアウトにも対応しています。テイクアウトはお電話（(262) 599-8900）でご注文ください。
OpenTable ダイナー23名によるThe Red Mill Innの評価は4.4☆です。