Tortoise Supper Club
Berkshire Pork Chop
Pommery Mustard Reduction, Grilled Asparagus, Smoked Cheddar Grits
Roasted Amish Chicken
Cilantro Sweet Chili Glaze, Buttery Mash Potatoes, Grilled Asparagus
Peanut Butter Pie
Chocolate Covered Pretzel Crust, Chocolate Creme Anglaise
So bad. It pains me to write a bad review considering the state of the restaurant industry right now but this was so bad.
They had the bartender waiting tables and bartending, granted there were not many people in there but 6 tables and ppl at the bar is too many ppl for 1 person to handle. My friend and I ordered the margarita on their special cocktail list and it was disgustingly sweet. But it took him so long to get back to us that we just drank them. We ordered the shrimp cocktail for an appetizer and it came out with 5 small shrimp with jarred cocktail sauce. For $19.99 I can't believe we didn't get so much as a lemon wedge… and 5 shrimp? Come on. We asked for lemon and again it took so long we had eaten the tiny shrimp.
She ordered the roast amish chicken which tasted like it was freezer burnt. I got the pork chop which came with a sauce that was super salty. It wasn't worth complaining bc again he didn't come back to check on us for at least 20 mins…
The cocktails were supposed to be half off (HH) but we were charged full price. Overall terribly disappointing and SO expensive. Would not recommend at all
Hello and thank you for getting in touch with us about your disappointing experience. We will certainly strive to do better and are so sorry your evening wasn't enjoyable at all. We are at least happy for the opportunity to speak to you in person and follow up. All the best from the Tortoise family
Our third visit and as special as always. Amazing cocktails—especially the whisky sour. Loved the shrimp scampi dip with Ritz crackers. Yum!
Excellent food and service. We always have a wonderful experience.
Server ruined our Sweetest Day Celebration. He was rude, condescending, and his behavior bordered on harassment. He wanted us to order and eat as fast as possible so that he could go home. We were constantly rushed and pushed to order our complete dinner ASAP. He consistently interrupted our thoughtful conversation and ruined our evening. We won’t be back with him working there.
Hi there and thank you for joining us at Tortoise Supper Club. I am so sorry you did not enjoy your experience with us, especially considering you chose to spend a celebratory event with us. I sincerely apologize. I would like to personally put you in touch with our owner, Keene Addington to discuss your experience. If you would be so kind, please get in touch with us and let us know how to reach you. We hope to hear from you soon. Best from all of us at Tortoise
Jazz night on Saturday. we love the food and service
For our last date night before the birth of our next child, we wanted a high-service blow out dinner night. We chose Tortoise Club, where we've dined many times. Once again, it was spectacular. Even in the age of Covid, our experience was spectacular. Matt, our server, like all the staff, were masked. They made our night fun and literally never missed a beat on a 4-course blowout. Our favorites were the octopus starter, the (fully dressed) wedge salad and the New York Strip au poivre. And of course, the Tortoise Pie. Now more than ever, these restaurants need your support and it's time to visit your old favorites. We are so glad we chose Tortoise Club again.
Hello, Jason, and thank you so much for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club for your last date night for a while. We're so glad to know the experience was everything you hoped. Thank you for taking the time write a review and for your continued support. We will be waiting for your return when you can a night away again! All the best from the Tortoise family.
The drinks were great, the food was amazing. The atmosphere was perfect for the occasion.
Hello and thank you for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club this weekend. Thank you for the kind words and we certainly hope you won't be a stranger. All the best from the Tortoise family.
Excellent food and service at Tortoise Supper Club! Will eat again and recommend!
Hello and thank you so much for the great thumbs-up! All the best from the Tortoise family.
I loved tortoise! Our server was excellent, our food was delicious and our drinks were superior! We also happen to manage scoring, what I would consider, the best seat in the piano bar!
Our server was attentive and had good recommendations. The octopus was smaller than we had thought but very tasty. Steak was perfectly cooked and seasoned. There were multiple people walking to the restrooms without any mask- and no one addressed. Servers walked by them without mentioning it - also, a table of more than six was sat as we were leaving. I am not sure if management is disregarding protocol but unfortunately, it did seem like it.
WONDERFUL! We are Tortoise's newest customers, and newest fans. Thank you for making it a special, personalized evening. We'll be back!
always a treat- impeccable and professional, wonderful ambiance
Hi there, Anne Marie, and thank you for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club. It's very gratifying to know you feel you can count on us to be "always a treat" and we hope to have you back soon. All the best from the Tortoise family.
Disappointed by the "Fish and Chips" but drinks and rest of the food was great.
Great venue for live jazz. Scallop entree was best in Chicago.
The food was excellent and the professionalism of the entire staff was amazing.
Hello, Aaron, and thank you for choosing the Tortoise Supper Club for your anniversary celebration. We're so glad to know we were able to make the night truly special and we hope you will be celebrating again with us in the future. All the best from the Tortoise family.
Wonderful dining experience with an attentive & knowledgable staff. Everything was savory & worth the visit, the ambience & their whiskey sour go hand-in-hand. Must visit, best!
Hi there and thank you so much for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club. We really appreciate that you took the time to review your experience and we're so glad it was worth the visit. We'll keep a Whiskey Sour on hand for your return visit! All the best from the Tortoise family.
Love this place! Serve and good are always amazing! Cocktails are extra yummy.
Hello there and thank you very much for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club. Thank you also for the very nice shout out. We hope you'll be back again soon! All the best from the Tortoise family.
Very nice experience and excellent service and food.
Hell, Glenn, and thank you for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club. Thank also for taking the time to write the nice review and we hope you'll be back soon. All the best from the Tortoise family.
Amazing staff, atmosphere, and food
Hello and thank you so much for the great thumbs-up! All the best from the Tortoise family.
It was perfect
Great time, food and service was excellent. Thanks!
Hello, Jeff, and we're so glad you had a great time at the Tortoise Supper Club. We certainly can't wait for you to be back. All the best from the Tortoise family.
We decided to celebrate our anniversary at Tortoise Supper Club. Having never been there we weren’t sure what to expect. As soon as we arrived, we were received warmly and led to a private room in the back of the restaurant and given two glasses of champagne and a kind note congratulating us on our anniversary. The service was incredible and very friendly. Despite being in the midst of a global pandemic, the staff went out of their way to provide us with a truly special night. We started with the relish tray, a true supper club classic and it was delicious!! Having spent many years of my life “Up North”, I’ve been in more than my fair share of supper clubs, the ambiance and menu reflect that experience perfectly. The French onion soup was executed flawlessly. I enjoyed the Saturday night Prime Rib special and my husband enjoyed the filet....both were cooked to perfection. Cocktails were fantastic. Honestly, I can’t say enough good things about this place. We will definitely be coming back and will be telling all of our friends.
Hello there, Daniel, and thank you so much for choosing the Tortoise Supper Club to celebrate your anniversary. We are so proud we were able to deliver a truly special night with the challenging state of dining out. Thank you also for taking the time to write such a nice review. We certainly hope your first time here wasn't your last, and we can celebrate with you again and again. All the best from the Tortoise family.
The preparation methods of the pork chop and Grits were executed poorly.
The pork chop was over cooked. It was very tough and the sauce that was used didn’t accent the meat. It really didn’t make any sense. A vingare based sauce of whatever was used was sour. Pork loves sweetness. You could of used those sour cherries in your cherry pie instead to make a sauce. Or made some sort of apple glazed
The cheese grits were under seasoned, had no flavor, and no cheese flavor.
Your methods for preparing the asparagus were on the level of a home cook. You left the stem or root on the bottom of the asparagus which doesn’t look good and you should of shaved the asparagus skin to make it look more appealing.
I would go back but only for drinks.
Hello, Gene, and thank you for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club. We're sorry you were so disappointed in your Pork Chop. If you'd be so kind as to contact the restaurant with a phone number or email I'd like to put you personally in contact with our owner, Keene Addington to discuss your experience. Please call and ask for George or email us through our website. All the best from the Tortoise family. George Baker Marketing Director
what an amazing experience! they gave our party a private back room which couldnt have been more perfect. the wait staff was SO attentive and kind and even let us stay past closing time! Thank you SO much Tortoise Club for this awesome experience!
Hi Jamie, and thank you for thinking of the Tortoise Supper Club for your gathering this weekend. We were happy to give your group a nice room so you could still enjoy a dinner together even if at separate tables. It's great to know you had such an amazing experience and we can't wait to see you again. All the best from the Tortoise family.
This is my favorite dining and music spot in the city. Fantastic food, paired with great wine, and live jazz on the weekends. A great place for a special night or just to unwind from the week.
Hello, Michael, and thank you so much for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club. It's great know we're your favorite dining spot and you appreciate the music, too. Thank you also for the about the service, we're very proud of our staff. All the best from the Tortoise family.
Wonderful dinner out with family- took our children, and restaurant was so gracious about them being there. Server was simply the best we’ve had or seen in years. His baritone first happy birthday ding was unrivaled and we felt very safe from a covid-pandemic standpoint, even dining in. Would highly recommend!
Hello there and thank you for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club. We were happy to welcome your children and we're so glad you were able to feel comfortable and safe while dining-in considering the covid situation. All the best from the Tortoise family.
We really enjoyed our dinner. Our servers Sergio and Manny were excellent. Loved the atmosphere. We decided to eat indoors as they reassured us they followed guidelines for covid, and they did. The food was excellent except for my son ordered the scallops with risotto and was disappointed with the risotto. I had the meatloaf, which was excellent, my husband had the prime rib, and my daughter in law the steak Diane, which they said was very good. We loved the relish tray. All of our cocktails were very good. The tortoise pie was to die for, and I had it with a scoop of bourbon ice cream. A little pricey, but all in all it was a very enjoyable experience.
Our sever was excellent and very knowledgeable about the menu. The food was delicious and we loved the classic supper club vibes.
Thank you so much for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club on Friday.We appreciate you mentioning your server, we're very proud of our staff. We're glad you loved our classic vibe and hope you're back to enjoy it again soon. All the best from the Tortoise family.
Best dining experience we have ever had. If I could give them 50 stars I would. The food was outstanding and the service was even better. Do yourself a favor and get here for dinner ASAP
Thank you so much for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club and giving us the opportunity to wow you! We're so glad you took the time to write such a nice review of your experience. All the best from the Tortoise family
Great vibe, outstanding service. Loved the relish tray!
Hello there and thank you so much for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club. It's so good to know you like our retro vibe and thanks for the shout out to the service. So glad you got a kick out of the Relish Tray! All the best from the Tortoise family.
12 year anniversary
This is one of our favorite go-to places, so it broke my heart a little to be the only people in the dining room for the entire night. Menu is still fabulous, food is consistently great and the service is always top-notch. They are completely adhering to all protocols, so there's no worry on that front. We're definitely going back again, and soon.
Hello and thank you so much for your loyalty to the Tortoise Supper Club. We're so glad you could come back and feel safe and comfortable. Though the main dining room was empty on your weeknight visit, we assure you the patio gets very full the rest of the weekend. We're so happy to be able to provide a fabulous men and "top-notch" service . We can't wait to have you back soon. All the best from the Tortoise family.
Can’t go wrong here!
Service was decent, but food was underwhelming. I ordered a medium NY Strip and they overcooked it. The Old Fashioned was more ice water than bourbon. We were sitting outside (b.c covid obviously), and noticed that their "Tortoise" sign was completely covered in spider webs and bugs.
Great family dinner. They have done a terrific job with the outside seating and the food was delicious. Can’t wait to get back
Hi Greg, and tank you for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club. It's great to know that even under the current restrictions we can still offer our guests and enjoyable dining experience. Can't wait for you to comeback. All the best from the Tortoise family.
We appreciated the availability of patio dining for an 80th birthday celebration. Luke our server was great.
Thank you, Mary, for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club. We're glad your group enjoyed their evening and appreciate your recognizing the staff. Glad to hear the Se Bass and Skirt Steak were excellent, and we're taking your Walleye notes to heart. We hope to see you again soon. All the best from the Tortoise family.
Live music was great -- definitely worth the trip.
Soup du jour was great (crawfish corn chowder). Chilean Sea Bass was very good, but overpriced. Pork chop was dry and tough -- definitely not up to the standards of the club.
Great, intimate dining experience. Staff his extensive familiarity with the menu and capable of providing excellent recommendations.
Thank you so much for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club. We are very proud of our staff and appreciate your mentioning them. All the best from the Tortoise family.
outside was very safe and tables spaced apart nicely
Hello, Valerie, and thank you for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club. Re-opening safely is the main priority here and we're so glad you felt you could enjoy our patio. We hope you'll drop in again soon. All the best from the Tortoise family
We were so pleased to return to the Tortoise Club after several delicious deliveries these last few months
The food was delicious and the service excellent! We love the food AND the drinks!
Hello, Judith, and thank you for joining us at the Tortoise Supper Club. We're so glad we were finally able to have you back in person. We appreciate you're taking advantage of our new delivery service during the shutdown and we hope to see you again and again now that we'reopen. All the best from the Tortoise family.
Tortoise Supper Clubはテイクアウトにも対応しています。テイクアウトはお電話（(312) 755-1700）でご注文ください。
OpenTable ダイナー2697名によるTortoise Supper Clubの評価は4.7☆です。