Sammy's Fish Box
Love this restaurant... just had a not so great meal tonight and service was off...
Wait was terrible. Lots of people but no place to put them. We had a reservation for 2 and waited 35 minutes to be seated. Once inside it was a nice experience.
I have not been there in 20 years ,line was long, I made a reservation and I was seated on time ,service was excellent Food was delicious .
Self care =crab legs
We were seated 30 min after our reservation time. The place totally packed. The food was average. Really expensive even though the portions are enormous. It's time to expand the size due to overcrowding.
Sammys is a favorite spot for my wife and I. Food and drinks are great.
Great service. Delicious food.
We went for lunch and were absolutely overwhelmed by the quality and quantity of the food. Go in the off season so you can just walk in and dive right in!
Great food and service. Does get crowded, but with good reason. Great Food
Food portions are great
I haven't been to Sammy's in almost 10 years. After a very mediocre experience at The Crab Shanty, I was in the market to find another place to have fried red snapper. The price here for one is $40. For that price I was expecting a huge fish. I received a medium sized one. The fish was heavily breaded so that took away from the taste of the snapper. It was oozing with oil which I noticed when I flipped it over. There was nothing underneath like a lettuce leaf to absorb it. The taste was mediocre at best. Wants the fresh, fishy taste I was expecting. I guess the hunt continues for the perfect red snapper.
My family and I are seafood lovers and I like the fact that Sammy's gives so many options on all price levels. Whenever we have a craving for seafood, we always go to Sammy's.
Everytime I go it is always good
New Year’s Eve dinner. I had my favorite dish shrimp stuffed with crabmeat and pasta in garlic sauce. Delicious 😋. My family had a great time spending New Years 2020 and the staff was very busy on top of that they had the best service as always. Love Sammy’s ♥️😊
It’s my mother 75 Birthday all her children and grandchildren enjoyed the restaurant
The experience for my family and I was just good. The waitress Adi was sweet, helpful, and very informative. At one point the manager came around and ask how was everything and was also very sweet.
The only complaint I have is with the hostess Tiffany. She is extremely dismissive and rude. As I could understand that it is very flustering dealing with a influx of customers and multiple people asking you questions, I did not appreciate how she continuously dismissed us when we asked about our reservation, and was very rude. She needs to be retrained as she is front of house and sets the tone for customers experience. Apparently it doesn’t make a difference whether or not you make a reservation on open table or not. The wait was not long fortunately but the hostess left a bad taste in my mouth.
Sammy's is and has been a stapled seafood location in City Island. The food and atmosphere were both good and "our" server was very helpful, kind and extremely polite during my dining experience. Yes - I would return to Sammy's and also recommend Sammy's Fish Box to a friend.
Sammy is always spectacular large delicious portions of piping hot fresh seafood and wonderful people that treat you like royalty
Geat time. Food was excellent.
It was a family outing to celebrate my anniversary, the food was great. It was fun for my girls to see Santa.
The food was great and really enjoy ourselves.
It was our wedding anniversary. Our celebration was acknowledged by one top official as well as the staff. It’s a great place for family get together.
Everything was perfect
Awesome as always
We had a great time! The food and drinks were great!
I love Sammy’s! Every time we’re in NY we have to dine here. I was born and raised in NYC and have been going to Sammy’s since childhood and it never ceases to amaze me that this restaurant has maintained its high standards for the food quality and service.
My favorite seafood restaurant! Always great food and service.
The food was lavish and delicious. On a holiday with huge crowds the service was great, polite, courteous and attentive. Parking was easy and convenient. When you go to Sammy's, make sure your stomach is nearly empty because the food comes in abundance.
It was awesome great food,great atmosphere, and great service. They sung happy birthday to my wife and gave her a complimentary dessert it was amazing definitely going to dine here every time we visit! Sammy’s is the shizit