Sarento's Italian Restaurant
Prepared traditional style
Fried Steak Calamari
Tender calamari strips, deep-fried and served with marinara
Sarento's signature piccata style with a hint of Barolo Red Wine, shiitake mushrooms, capers, lemon, linguini
The staff was very nice and accommodating to our large group. Very nice place and the food was delicious. Would recommend for a special occasion
Restaurant was great! Open table totally has the wrong address for the restaurant though.
Amazing food and service!! Will definitely be back!
1st time and the food and drinks were outstanding. Definitely will return!
Lobster Ravioli was outstanding.
A little ambiance. Food very bland and not good! Out of desserts at 5pm! Not impressed
Waiter was overwhelmed with amount of tables but he remained pleasant. We waited a long time to order dessert and to get our bill but I suppose this is due to lack of staffing because of Covid. Food was very good.
Service was great. Several menu items and desserts were not available already at 6pm. Seafood Cannelloni special had artificial seafood mixed in with the real shrimp. Very disappointing for a $30 pasta entree that said nothing about artificial seafood in the description (crab, shrimp, and scallops). Lasagna entree had way too much garlic and it overpowered the dish. The food looked good, and we wanted to like this place, but it was really just ok at best, especially for the price. $100 without drinks, appetizers, or tip. There are very few Italian restaurants in the Dells, but we will not be going back to this one in the future. Once and done. My recommendation: wait to go back home to your favorite Italian restaurant for half the price. The reviews on this place are very up and down. Those who rank it high are often just happy because they were able to seat a large party. The food is nothing to write home about. Try a different place. We certainly will be.
Great menu selection, outstanding service. Will do again when in the area.
The food was fantastic. My only complaint is they rush you. They don’t let you sit there and enjoy your meal. They come and take your food away they take your plates away they bring the food too quickly. I wanted to relax with my cocktail and it’s too rushed
The food and service were excellent as usual, and everything was extremely well kept, almost as though it was new. Sarento's is one of our "go to" preferred Italian restaurants in Wisconsin, offering a great menu that includes my wife's favorite dish of Linguini & Clams in a white wine sauce. My adult son loved the Gnocchi with pomodoro sauce (option of gorgonzola or marinara sauces also).
I always order the Tagliatelle Bolognese, which is a unique recipe of wine, cream, vegetable & beef stock reduction combined with beef, pork and veal to create meat sauce atop tagliatelle. I have found nothing like this at other restaurants, so it is a must try!
We saved half of our entrees to take home so we would have room for one of ten dolce (dessert) choices. All are home made, including the ice cream inside the Spumoni Tort. The Italian Cream Cake was decadently sweet, moist and flavorful. Most are large enough to share, but we splurged for our anniversary and each had our own. I am glad we did.
Highly recommended on all accounts!
Ryan was wonderful. Super attentive to our needs. Food was outstanding! One of the best veal piccata I have ever had.
Authentic Italian food! The lasagna and pizza was delicious! Definitely check it out
Waiter was probably new. Obviously short staffed as most places are. Fish was very good but our orders were mixed up with our side dishes. Broccoli was ice cold. Had to ask several times for our bread.
Excellent food and service.
Hernando and the service team was excellent! We will be back! Food was great too, nice evening
Service was great. Staff very attentive and meals were delicious.
If your looking for a quiet romantic place to have dinner with your partner on your anniversary, don’t go here. This is more like a sports bar or loud family dining experience. Iceberg lettuce in salads was disappointing. Too many cream sauces featured on main dishes. Servers were excellent though!
The breadsticks are a great start! We suggest you upgrade to the Sarento salad or French onion soup. Our guests enjoyed the portion size and quality of the Friday special battered fried cod. The shrimp scampi is top notch! Service was great!
Staff was pleasant and efficient.
Food was not good, overall ok but would not return.
Our table wasn’t ready for our reservation. The one blonde bartender was very nice the other female bartender (had an accent) was somewhat rude & very impatient when she was dealing with our party. Our server was nice but very rushed & didn’t come back to us in a timely manner to check in on us. My dinner was inedible ($18) & she did not even seem to care when I shared that & we were ready to almost leave when she finally asked. She did not even respond with a comment & did not even make eye contact. VERY disappointed & VERY expensive. We won’t go back. Very pricey for mediocre service.
Food and service were great. We went on a Sunday evening and it was not crowded. We had not requested a quieter area but didn’t realize there was a choice between the dining room and the bar area. We were seated in the bar area and we would not do that again.
Great italian restaurant!
We were on a family vacation, and decided to treat the family to a nicer dinner as a treat. Excellent food, nice ambiance, and good service!
Not exceptional. The service was not what we expected. We needed to ask for bread, water and drink refills instead of the servers asking us. The servers weren’t attentive or thinking ahead. Food was okay except for my New York strip. It was very strange and tough to cut.
Not terrible but nothing made us want to come back soon.
Worst service I’ve had in a long time. If you hate being a waitress so much, maybe find a new job.
Been going to Sarento’s for years as we visit Wis. Dells. Unfortunately, this time will mark the last time. The sauces tasted like it was from a can. The scallops were very fishy. The calamari was waaay over-cooked and the oil it was fried in tasted old. The Service staff was very attentive and helpful, and was the best part of the meal.
Best friend’s Birthday!
Everyone was very satisfied with the food they ordered. The lasagna could have been made with pasta that was a little bit thicker. Prices were reasonable, service was great. Will definitely be going back.
One of the best italian restaurants around . The interior had a amazing artist put some amazing finishes..and who could ever say it more perfect on the menu ...in regards to the steak temperatures ...all n all food atmosphere service all top notch....
first visit for Valentine's Day! it was wonderful all the way around. Food was outstanding and definitely home made. Great service and a nice atmosphere.
Absolutely wonderful! The seafood trio is by far one of the best things ive had.
This was a last minute plan for us. Our dinner was absolutely amazing. We wish we didn't live so far away. We highly recommend Sarento's.
The bolognese was fabulous!! There was live music with a woman singing and a guy with a guitar and they were really good. It was nice to have the music in the background while having dinner.
Vinyl table cloths
A great place to bump into old friends.
coffee and water needed to be filled more often
music was wonderful
Salad was amazing
eggplant seemed like a from scratch recipe
Friday fish fry. Everything was excellent. Will be back.
Too expensive for the quality of service. Wrong side dish was served, no desert was offered.
Super service always at Sarento’s. It’s what keeps us coming back along with the amazing food.
Sarento's Italian Restaurantはテイクアウトにも対応しています。テイクアウトはお電話（(608) 253-3300）でご注文ください。
OpenTable ダイナー193名によるSarento's Italian Restaurantの評価は4.4☆です。