Scalini Fedeli - Chatham

We were recommended this restaurant by family members. It was one of the best meals we have ever had. You will not regret it! The service is top notch, the drinks are fabulous, the food is unbelievable and it was one of our best meals to date. Alex's service, kindness and personality made the evening as well. You do not want to miss out! Make a reservation, you will not be sorry.

The best italian food in NJ, hands down its not even close.

Wonderful dinner. Fantastic service.

Food and service is incredible. Highly recommend.

Fine dining at its finest. The food is always outstanding as is the service. Since the COVID outbreak fine dining has changed drastically, not at Scalini Fedeli. Top notch. Looking forward to our next meal at SF.

Service was great food was outstanding. The pork chop was to die for

My wife and I had lunch at Scalini Fedeli to celebrate her 65th Birthday. The restaurant was empty. We were the only one's having lunch. While it was nice to have the place to ourselves. It still felt strange.

The food was very good. We shaved the shrimp appetizer. My wife had duck for her main course and I had the pork chop.

We always enjoy going to this restaurant, but haven't because of the pandemic.

OUTSTANDING.

Not my first rodeo with Scalini, but first time during COVID....went to a Prefixe menu, but was all quite outstanding....brought my own wine, but preceded with a cocktail from their bar...excellent. Mad props to the staff and chef.

Cheers,

Food and service were excellent. Haven't been in years and it continues to be a great restaurant!

Still the best restaurant in the area! The environment was perfect, very safe, food and service fabulous.

Incredible food and outstanding service. Wonderful New Years Eve experience.

Wonderful safe experience

Christmas Eve.

Incredible ! Can’t wait to go back.

Celebrated our anniversary. The service was impeccable. The food was amazing. Truly one of the best dining experiences I have ever had

Love this place .. dessert aren’t my favorite but highly recommend trying this restaurant for a special occasion

The waiter was very attentive and helpful. It was our first time there and we felt the value for the price of the menu versus the quality and the quantity of the food was well worth it. Loved the snapper and chocolate soufflé. Highly recommend!

More of a "couples" place. Excellent!
Went with a couple of school buddies. Not conducive to "guys" night out.

This restaurant is definitely the gold standard for Italian food the area. Every dish is authentic, well prepared, elegant and delicious! We absolutely recommend it especially if you're tired of red-sauce Italian restaurants which are so prolific in NJ

The food was succulent and superb .
Very tasty and well seasoned.

What a treat! Fine dining at it’s best with equally refined service.

Best dinner I have had in NJ for years. Seriously, everything was great. And big portions too. We were plenty full and ended up taking another meal’s worth of food home.

Amazing food and service! The best food I’ve had in a long time for The price.

We had the most delicious wonderful dinner
Andres is a great waiter

Unbelievable. Will absolutely return.

Upscale Italian, a longtime fixture in Chatham. Lovely decor-service a little slow in the time of COVID but attentive. The food, from amuse bouche to dessert, remains exceptional.

As always the food & service were outstanding. This is our birthday celebration restaurant every year!

Always great!

Excellent meal as always. Service was good but seemed a little rushed.

We arrived about 10 minutes early , we ended up waiting over 20 minutes while a table for 13 was seated with out reservations. We had to ask the hostess about our table which was empty for over 15 minutes.
This was our 25th wedding anniversary.
First my drink had a bug in it. I explained to the waiter that I was allergic to nuts. I order the desert to come without nuts in the ice cream and the first bite there were nuts in it. Potential death .

Everything was spectacular
This is my go to place for all special occasions
Every bite is better then the next
LOVE LOVE LOVE

Absolutely beautiful and romantic And friendly staff

Great food and a very good value given the quality, especially since you can bring one bottle of wine per couple.

Never, ever disappoints !!! Highly recommend !!!

Great food and service. I have never been disappointed at Scalini!! Highly recommended.

I have eaten in 100's of restaurants around the world, and I have never had a better experience than I did at Scalini Fideli. From start to finish everything was excellent, especially the food, which was exceptional. If you want to experience a world class restaurant right here in New Jersey, head to Scalini Fideli. You will not be disappointed.

The creativity of the menu was unlike anything we’ve ever experienced. Food quality was second to none. We enjoyed the prix-fixe arrangement. This was a restaurant that we’d intended on traveling to for years, and it exceeded the hype. Absolutely phenomenal.

Excellent food, service and ambiance!

An amazing gastronomic experience from start to finish! I can’t this level of dining is available in this humble part of New Jersey. Sauces to die for! Home made pastas. Heavenly Soufflé! Totally impressed my date!

Great food!