I was there to celebrate my mother's 93rd birthday. Everything was outstanding. She was a little disappointed that they did not have frog legs but she was fine with ordering the coconut shrimp. Thank you to our waitress Melissa, she made my mother's birthday very special. The people sitting around us also sang Happy Birthday to my mom.
Flounder entree was very good with great service
Our favorite restaurant Downriver! Everything is delicious, from the main course, to the sides, to the desserts.
food just ok not hot server forgot to put in order so service was slow no compensation offered
Food was very good and plentiful The dining pace was great with the attentive server Kali THANKS
New Year’s Eve
Not one of our best experiences. Made to feel like we were a bother to staff as they devoted all their attention to their regulars.
The service was prompt; we were seated right away. The food was delicious; the waitress was polite. We had a good time.
Downriver’s Gem. Great food and atmosphere.
Sibley never disappoints.
May be my most frequented restaurant. Classic old fashioned Italian American restaurant, except for the fact that they make Italian food correctly, their veal is particularly good. Broad menu, to serve most any patron. Amazing deserts, seafood and specials. All for a reasonable price for the quality of the food that you get. Oh, and best steak you will find outside of a dedicated, high end (read much more expensive), Steak House, and they are still better than many of those I have been too. Impossible to not mention the amazing staff. They have been wonderful every time I have been there. A downriver institution. The area would not be the same without them.
One of the best places for fine dining in the downriver area.
Just can’t beat the Steak Sammy!
We love this place! It’s a hidden gem! Great food and service!
The Garden has been solid with their food and service, since the first time I dined there 45 years ago. Old School
Great food & service, Always an enjoyable experience dining there
Great local restaurant! Always enjoy the holiday atmosphere here.
We were seated on dining room side after being told there were no seating available on bar side when I booked reservation, after being seated another party came in and asked if there was anything available on bar side and was told absolutely and was seated on bar side. During dinner all the waitstaff was standing in front of room and just acting like a party was going on, very loud, was not an enjoyable evening at all!!!
Was very good food, good service. That being said very pricey for what you get. Shrimp cocktail is a great example at $14, and you get 4 shrimp.....
Really good food....
I had a steak that was great, the fried mushrooms were great and so was the service.
Love this place! It’s like stepping back in time (but in a good way). Food was exceptional and service was great, as always!
Early Sweetest Day
Terrific dinner and service!
I haven’t been here in many years. The food was still exceptional. Just as I remembered. Our server was extremely preoccupied. She got our order wrong, didn’t bring us bread and really was less than attentive. It was so loud in the restaurant.
I don’t think so. It was our anniversary we sat by a group of high school kids who were well behaved but still loud. They were out of meat for the ravioli never refilled bread took an hour for food
Great food and service. Had loud table of six close to ours. They were yelling back and forth between the ends of the table. We tried to relocate but were told that all other tables were reserved. We WILL be back!!!!
My daughter’s favorite choice for birthday dinner. Ambience is wonderful, consistently great food, respectable wine list, well-stocked bar for cocktails, very good crepe brûlée, cannolis, and tiramisu, and friendly waitstaff. We almost always get the filet, but the scallops and oysters are great too! A Downriver treasure.
We don't enjoy the Dining Room side because the sound is magnified and we can't hear each other speak. Generally, we ask for the bar side, but there was a special entertainer on that side that night.
Excellent service and food. We brought our son and his wife for their anniversary.
We have been going to Sibley's for many years. One of our favorite places to eat downriver. The food is always delicious, service is friendly, quick and accomodating. We prefer to be on the bar side, more to see! Never disappointed in food or service. AMAZING! Must go if you have not prior.
With all the praise, the last three times we have been here to eat. We always get margarita's on the rocks. They usually are amazing. Tart and strong. I believe they have a new bartender. The margarita last night, 9/24/19. Was weak and watery. This makes 3x's that we have been disappointed in our drinks. If you're using a new mix, go back. If you got a new bartender, switch. Learn/teach how to make a proper margarita. PLEASE!
The food was delicious! Even better than the food was the outstanding service we received from Tracie. She was awesome 👏
Has always been one of my favorite restaurants. Great quality food and an awesome staff
Best place downriver. Steaks are wonderful. Always ask for sizzle platter for the steak. Escargot is a favorite. Caesar salad with blackened tenderloin is a great choice. Very relaxed mobster feeling hangout with rich leather booths. Very comfortable. They treat you like family. All cocktails and wine are with a pretty heavy pour - get your money’s worth, which is great.
I was so excited to go here after I’ve heard great things however our waitress was very rude, the calamari I expected to be fresh but it was the frozen kind that is like thick frys and I didn’t care for the dip they served with it. It reminded me of a Mexican style ranch. The coconut shrimp was a good size, however the grease was clearly old because it tasted like it was burnt and that followed through with the Sicilian medallions I got for dinner. All I tasted was old grease and unfortunately it effected the overall flavor even when I tried removing the breading. Our server was overly friendly with the regulars but didn’t even look up at us or acknowledge us when pouring our water or when I would say thank you. She never came back to the table to ask how our dinner was. While My husband enjoyed his scallop dinner he said he’s had better. I wanted so badly to love this place but I didn’t get the enjoyment out of that most do. When asking our waitress what the “Sammy Sauce” was because we’ve never been here before she replied I don’t know, I asked is it like a Au Jus? She replied I don’t know and shrugged. The atmosphere is romantic but what good is that with the server is rude and the food is not the best. The bus boy and host however were very sweet and friendly.
Great dinner at Sibley’s. Consistently great!
Our reservation was for a table in the bar, but we were seated in a booth. The booths by the bar are too small for 4. We asked to be moved to a table. The staff was very accommodating!! We had a fantastic drink by the bar, thank you bartender!, and were seated at a great table, had excellent service, and the food was fantastic, as usual!
The move made for a much better dining experience. The staff has a as excellent as the food. Thank you!
Love the Chicken Picante! Great with a special baked potato!