The Mill in Hershey
Wonderful dinner! Our server Matt L was awesome! Can’t wait to return!!
Food and ambiance were amazing!
The service was excellent and the food and drinks outstanding.
My wife and I made a reservation for a Saturday evening and were seated promptly upon our arrival. We found the choices of appetizers and main courses all looked tasty. The pacing of the meal was appropriate and the food was excellent. Our server was attentive and addressed our needs promptly.
Excellent atmosphere, food delicious, prices modest. Wait staff very helpful and friendly, but yet not overly friendly.
Excellent find!! Everything was superb. I can’t wait to go again!
Excellent dinner, as always. A little pricey, but reasonable for food quality and portion size. If you’re looking for something quieter and cozier than the main dining area, request a seating downstairs - despite the large bar area, the low ceiling and nooks create a more intimate ambience.
Great ambiance and design, unfortunately food did not match up. Not bad, just nothing special.
Our experience was fantastic . Our server made our night she was very professional and fun to be around
Absolutely amazing food!! The fried Brussel sprouts were delicious, and I wish we'd gotten two helpings of the poutine! Since it was Fall, I had a Moscow Mule with Fireball and cinnamon, and it's probably the best mule I've ever had. The service was friendly and attentive. If I'm in Hershey again, there's no doubt I will be stopping by!
We have gone to the Mill a few times and this particular time the service was lousy and the noise level was extreme as we were placed in a room with a large party. When we were first seated we were put at a table that had water dripping on it and brought it to the serving assistant attention. The serving assistant moved us, with no comment from our server nor did the manager come over to our table to apologize for the disruption.
We were never asked to new drinks and my husband was never asked about coffee, each time we had to get the waitress. Very disappointing for the price.
Wine list is very inadequate. Squash salad was an interesting dish.
A little too bright in basement. Not as cozy as 1st floor.
Food and drinks were great - food choices were great - server was attentive. Only thing that was a bit of a downer was that the noise level was a little high, making it hard to hear.
Overall a very good experience. Exceptional service. My roasted pork loin was served medium rare. To serve well done it was returned to kitchen and flame broiled, changing the entire flavor profile of the dish because the pork now had a charcoal burned outer crust. The flavor profile of the dish and marriage to fall accompaniments was ruined. Had the pork been roast to traditional standards the dish would have been exceptional. Instead it was a smokey, charcoaled pork with roast pork sides. My strong recommendation is to not serve rare pork unless the guest has been pre-informed and consents.
Great restaurant for a special occasion or celebration with outstanding food!
We have been to the Mill several times before but this time, the service left a bit to be desired, especially for a Tuesday night when it wasn’t packed. The service started out great when we sat down to order drinks and appetizers. Then, we placed an order for entrees and drinks we intended to have with dinner. Our entrees came out from people who were not our server and our server neglected to check back with us to ensure our meals came out as ordered and she finally brought us our “dinner” drinks after we had all finished our meals. By the way, the drinks weren’t complicated- a beer, a glass of wine, and a margarita. The food was very good though. We enjoyed the brussell sprouts as a starter and our entrees were all delicious. We would go back but it likely wouldn’t be our first choice due to the service being so slow.
Always enjoy our meal at The Mill, love the downstairs dining room.
Jessica was our server and she was lovely and accommodating.
The food was very good as always. We enjoy the atmosphere in this old mill. Our waitress, Amanda was excellent!
Our service, Matt, is fun and friendly. He recommended the Halibut special. We took his advice. It was delicious! Other food on the menu are amazing. We will definitely come back again. It was warm and we love the style of “barn”.
Food was PHENOMENAL ! highly recommend eating here. Staff was super friendly and helpful. I raved about our date night to everyone the following day. Will be back for sure!
Got burgers. Poorly done either bloody or well done burnt. No med well. Better to get burger at McD.
👍🏻 Quality food, service and atmosphere. Had the brisket meal ...Awesome!
Everything was awesome. Best meal we had all week! Service was terrific! Thank you!
The food was delicious and the waitress was nice.
We celebrated our 30th anniversary and had a wonderful meal with great service, highly recommend
Excellent!!! We'll be back!!! Great waitress. Wonderful food. Enjoyed!!!
Seated right away. Server was excellent. Food was good. Squash salad while very tasty, did not contain much squash. Reuben on the other hand was both tasty, exactly as expected and of good volume. We would go back to this place. We were there on a very busy rainy day for brunch.
A few friends recommended The Mill, so we checked it out. Our Brunch date couldn't have gone any better. The drinks were great, food was delicious, service was fantastic, and the atmosphere was just perfect. It was not loud at all in the downstairs for brunch time.
Different! Love the farm-chic ambient. Food was outstanding!
My husband luv the brisket!
Great food. The menu was a bit different from our mid-western offering. Very enjoyable. The server did a good job of balancing interuptions and allowing us to talk. She made good suggestions for the food. All in all it was a good addition to our Mother/Daughter trip.
Best place in Hershey as always. Never disappoints. Christine (our waitress) is probably the most knowledgeable person there. Can’t ask her a question about the menu she doesn’t know.
Food and service were both amazing!
Excellent place to have a business meal with clients.
Food & staff was great.
Food was fabulous!!!! But....seated immediately, but waited 20 minutes before I had to get out of my chair to ask for a waiter. Waiter indicated he was not told he had another table and brought it up several times during the course of our meal. The Mill graciously comped our drink order. But the drinks were included on our bill when it was time to settle up. Again, waiter claimed the drinks were removed from the bill. Bill was corrected before we left.
We made our reservations on OpenTable and were seated immediately when we arrived. The food tasted amazing. The portion sizes were good and the service was great!
I really liked the menu.
Great place for a date night. Food and drinks were great. Beautiful place.