Excellent! We were seated immediately and water and bread were brought to the table. We heard the specials and decided on the calamari appetizer, the ravioli appetizer, seafood risotto as our main and finished with the flourless chocolate cake. Perfect from start to finish!
All dishes were presented beautifully and were flavorful and perfectly prepared. Was surprised that the halibut special did not come with salad or starch side dish, just string beans. Granted they were perfect but at $34 I would have expected at least a tiny dollop of mashed potato or rice.
My reservation was cut down to a party of 1. My server was friendly, accommodating and the food was fabulous!
Awesome as usual! Never a bad meal, no issues. Waitress was great too! Love Tisha’s♥️
Nice meal and great service!
We ordered the seafood pescatore snd had an abundance of seafood. The harvest salad was also very good. Would return.
We eat at Tisha's several times a year and we are never disappointed.
Service was amazing and the food was outstanding !!!
Consistent delicious favorites. Best chowder.
My husband and i sat outside last night and had a super dinner. The waitstaff was very accommodating. The food was yummy and the cheesecake was to die for. Super cream cheese cheese cake with a side of real whipped cream. The people at near by tables seemed to be really enjoying their meals and experience as well. Lovely evening
Food was fabulous
Lovely outdoor back patio and great service.
Crab cake sandwich was large and tasty on a very nice, buttery bun. I opted for the salad with it and was slightly disappointed as it was just two types of lettuce with no other veggies - and I don’t like one of the lettuces. My friend opted for fries instead and enjoyed them.
BYOB is a welcome option and they offer Cape May winery products if you didn’ bring yours.
Everything positive posted regarding this restaurant was accurate. The food and service were exceptional. The server to the hostess went out of their way to make the lunch experience memorable.
It was our wedding anniversary and it was so nice to be congratulated by the host wand the server on our arrival. Food was spectacular as always
My wife and I enjoyed our Scallop Risotto with spinach and shitake mushrooms, however I personally was a little disappointed in the size of the Scallops that we were served for the price. If they were sea scallops, they were quite small, if they were not they should have been.
Normally I really enjoy the lunch portions more.
Great food and atmosphere for birthday dinner
Food was excellent! Service was great Definitely a place to revisit.
Great food and service, consistently excellent.
Booked well in advance (recommended) for our anniversary dinner. Service here is very good - veteran staff not summer kids. Atmosphere / ambiance is not what you pay for here. The majority of the seating is outside with a view of a parking lot in the back and the shoppers in the front - inside is very clean but basic. The highlight here is definitely the food which is outstanding. If you enjoy perfectly prepared 'normal' fine dining (no nitrogen flash frozen flowers) this is a great spot. I'd recommend any of the seafood options but heard folks raving about the quality of their steaks too. We were too full for dessert but they sounded delicious. BYOB so you can splurge on your entree! I do wish, as almost everywhere, that they had better stemware. I don't want to look prudish by bringing my own stemware ... maybe places could start adding a "stemware corkage" fee if you want upgraded glassware.
A very good meal along with excellent service. My wife and I both had the special and could not have been more pleased with the meal. Always a nice evening at Tishas.
Out food was outstanding and our server Kat, was wonderful!!
Great service and great food
Excellent surprise on our first trip to Cape May. I would recommend this restaurant to anyone who is in this seashore town. Our waitress Jessica, is a great host and helped with our selections.
Fantastic! Great service! Started with the special appetizer of burrata, tomato and beet salad. We had the Thai salmon and filet, both delicious. Best meal on our trip.
Our favorite dinner place at the shore.
Given the ratings, we were somewhat disappointed. We went to Tisha's for lunch, and had a peasant table on the porch looking into Washington Street Mall. Server was pleasant but not especially attentive (I had to ask for more water, and it took a little while before she returned with a pitcher). I had the crab cake sandwich; my wife, the crab tacos. Since we are originally from Baltimore, we appreciate a well-made lump meant crab cake. This crab cake was shredded and had too much breading, although it was a generous size and tasted OK. Same can be said for taco. I also had the New England clam chowder, which was good but not memorable. In sum, Tisha's was fine for lunch but not necessarily a better choice that other restaurants in the mall area. Perhaps it shines at dinner.
Great evening at Tishas. Very accommodating to family of 6.
My husband and I both had the filet mignon on the recommendation of our daughter. It was cooked to perfection. The sides were excellent as well.
Delicious fresh well prepared food. Halibut special with crab and white wine sauce was fantastic. We ate outside on a nice night.
Thai salmon is my go to dinner- always excellent. Great service
My husband and I really enjoyed our meal at Tisha’s. Scallops with mushroom risotto was so good that I am still thinking of it. The filet au poivre was perfectly cooked, which is not easy for almost well done— still tender and juicy, served over tasty potatoes and fresh, crisp green beans. We felt safe sitting on the front porch, where we could also watch the passing parade of people strolling by. A memorable first meal out after lockdown.
Tisha’s never disappoints. We were quite happy with our meal.
Food and service was amazing! And it’s BYO!
Tisha’s is consistently excellent. And our server Schuyler made the experience that much more memorable. She was fabulous!
Tisha's always provides a great meal
We love this place our favorite
Great food, nice place to celebrate something and it's nice that it's byob
Excellent service. Our server, Dianna, was very pleasant and efficient. We dined at opening time, and while it was very busy, we never felt neglected or rushed. The calamari appetizer was the best I have had in a long time! Everything was absolutely delicious!!
Food, service & overall experience was faniminal. Will return again very soon. ❤